Understanding Confucius: A Rhetorical Reading of Ren,Yi,and Li

来源 :2012北京大学新闻传播伦理与法制国际学术研讨会 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:aolongjiutian
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  We have made great strides in understanding some important cultural differences.In the Rhetoric,we have come to see,Aristotle teaches about the individual,the victorious,and the rational,while in the Analects,Confucius teaches about the family,the deferent,and the conversational.We have come to a point,however,that we want to bemore careful so as to produce more useful generalizations.Take the characterizations of Aristotles and Confuciusteachings above as an example.It is true that Aristotle says the substance of rhetoric is the enthymeme,the rhetorical syllogism (1354a15),and that Confucius teaches through analogy ([近取譬,可謂仁之方也已.] 6.28),induction of sorts.But the conclusion that Confucius would have no idea of or any interest in rhetoric as Aristotle discusses it should be problematic to anyone who has read the Rhetoric and the Analects.Similarities and differences are intertwined;therefore,to untwine them for the purpose of understanding cultural differences,we must do so carefully.This paper presents a reading of Confucius teaching of ren,yi,and li in the Analects as both similar and different from Aristotles teaching of epiecia,kairos,and topoi in the Rhetoric.They both emphasize the dynamic relation between form and matter,but they value defining that relationship differently.I will first problematize the simplistic reading of Aristotles rhetoric and then explain Confucius rhetorical thinking.We understand cultural difference for harmony(和),which presupposes differences.Therefore,I challenge neither the existence of differences nor the value of knowing them.On the contrary,precisely because understanding differences is so crucial to our goal of harmony,we must be careful.The paper will conclude with examples of how this rhetorical reading helps with cross-cultural understanding.
其他文献
目的:强化感染管理在感染科护理中的应用效果.方法:选取104例在我院发热门诊就诊的病人进行调查与分析,本次调查时间在2019.01-2020.12.将病人分为2组,每组分得52例.对比组采
  辊压机联合粉磨系统目前已经成为水泥粉磨系统的首选方案。本文将针对联合粉磨系统的特点,结合具体项目的设计和该系统在生产调试中出现的一些情况,进行了分析探讨,供同行们
目的:探究医护一体化快速康复护理在慢性化脓性中耳炎患者围手术期中的应用.方法:选择在本科室治疗慢性化脓性中耳炎的23例患者,将其作为本次调查的对象,采用随机数字表法将
目的:研究迈瑞全自动血液分析流水线的日常维护及常规故障排查.方法:实施前即2018年9月至2019年9月,实施后即2019年10月至2020年10月,分析迈瑞全自动血液分析流水线的故障现
会议
  Since the oldest rhetorical treatises the persuasive power of the ethos of the speaker has been a certainty.At the beginning of his Rhetoric Aristotle consi
会议
本文主要通过实验比较抗阻训练和平跑训练,证明哪一种训练法是发展短跑运动员的最大速度的最好方法。并从动力学特征上对两种训练形式进行比较。得出抗阻训练方法对短跑运动
目的:分析针灸严重晕针患者的临床特征.方法:选取本院2例针灸严重晕针患者的病历资料进行回顾性研究,分析其临床症状与表现,总结预防、告知、治疗与处治方法.结果:2例患者经