An economic analysis of preservation versus development of coastal wetlands around the Youngsan Rive

来源 :海洋经济与海洋强国建设国际研讨会 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:lishao_minlimin
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  This paper addresses the specific benefits and costs for converting coastal wetlands around the Youngsan River in Korea into agricultural use.In conventional benefit-cost analysis (BCA) excluding passive-use values, two scenarios are employed: in Scenario 1 it is assumed that the effects of agricultural production and its air quality improvements occur after 10 years from the beginning of the project.With this optimistic estimate this period is 5 years shorter than the status quo due to the expected technical advances for removing the salt from reclaimed land.Scenario 2 is assumed that the period is normally 15 years without considering the technical changes.The results shows wetland development is preferred to its preservation in Scenario 1,yielding NPV of $ 49,030 thousand at the discount rate of 8 %, and IRR of 8.28 %, B/C ratio of 1.03.In contrast to Scenario 1, Scenario 2 rejects economic feasibility for the development project at the discount rate of 8%, yielding a negative NPV of $271,575 thousand, IRR of 6.5 % and B/C ratio of 0.84.In sensitivity analysis, a change of agricultural production factor is most sensitive to a change of IRR under Scenario 1, while under Scenario 2 the cost factor of fishing rights lost is most sensitive.With an argument of extended BCA including passive-use values, the estimates of IRR are 7.42 %, 5.42 %, and 4.06 % for 1 year-payment, 5 year-payment, and 10 year-payment of passive-use values, respectively under Scenario 1.Under Scenario 2 the estimates of IRR are 5.85 %, 4.25 %, and 3.09 %, respectively.They show that consideration of passive-use in BCA can play a crucial role in reversing the results suffered by weak persuasion for wetland preservation.Further analysis using a goal-seeking model produces the specific minimum magnitudes of passive-use values so as to preserve wetlands in this project according to national level and household level with some different possible discount rates (5%,6 %, and 7 %).If about fifty-eight percent of all households in Korea can have their annual WTP of $ 5 to $16 for preserving wetlands only for 10 years, wetlands would progressively be protected even under the worst scenarios of low discount rates.Finally, this paper provides a direct and intuitive comparison of total wetland preservation value and total development values for agricultural use.The results illustrate that total value of wetland preservation is about three times much higher than that of development for agricultural use, even though this method is quite sensitive to criteria and methods of resource allocation.It is noteworthy that only agricultural use will be less efficient than wetland preservation if the project does not include industrial use of reclaimed lands.
其他文献
铁路旅游是中国旅游业的重要模块之一,本文采用国内外对比研究方法,对国际铁路旅游产品进行研究,总结了国外铁路旅游产品的一些特点,如美国人性化的车厢和周到的服务、欧洲和
党的十八大报告明确指出,要加快发展现代农业,着力促进农民增收,坚持和完善农村基本经营制度,构建集约化、专业化、组织化、社会化相结合的新型农业经营体系,加快完善城乡发
文章介绍了家庭农场的发展现状,办好“家庭农场”,有助于提高农业的整体效益,有助于生产与市场的对接,克服小生产与大市场的矛盾,提高农业生产、流通、交换、消费全过程的组织化程
本文基于2002-2011年"金砖五国"创意商品贸易发展的相关数据,采用Lafay指数和贸易互补性指数(TCI)对金砖五国创意商品的国际竞争力、互补性、产业内贸易水平等贸易结构方面进
通过介绍当今国际贸易的发展情况,认为全球价值链的形成,使国际服务贸易的结构呈现出了新的变革,发展服务贸易的重要性日益凸显,提出完善服务贸易的政策,主动融入全球价值链需要鼓
通过介绍北京的总体服务贸易的发展情况,探索了其未来的发展趋势,指出针对其存在的问题,提出在优化贸易结构,提升贸易竞争力,鉴改善贸易管理体制,加强产业集群的国际化导向等方面的
本文以美、日、欧为代表的发达国家和以金砖国家为代表的发展中国家为研究对象,借用其成功经验中的重要特质——生产性服务业和出口贸易,尝试在开放环境下,以各国生产性服务
  This paper presents results from a European research project that has investigated novel technologies which are able to recover the fresh quality after fres
会议
  Based on the suggestions made by the Report on the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China that China should enhance its capacity for develop
  Along with national economic development and the increase of citizens income, the aquatic product is occupying for an increasingly large distribution m citi