A Unified Framework for Analyzing and Improving Individual and Group Judgment

来源 :第一届决策与脑研究国际研讨会(THE 1stINTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON DECISION MA | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:wlhkbbc
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  After decades of research,the social sciences still lack an integrative theoretical framework for analyzing and improving group judgment.I propose that connecting group decision making research with insights from machine learning and statistical theory could help us develop such a framework and answer these questions.The framework,based on decomposing the prediction error of group judgment into bias,variance,and covariance,makes it possible to determine when and why groups perform better than individuals and to devise new ways of improving the accuracy of group judgment.I use computer simulations to estimate the bias-variance profiles of cue- and exemplar-based strategies and the bias-variance-covariance profiles for groups of these strategies.The results show that exemplar-based strategies benefit the most from averaging,due to lower bias and higher variance compared to cue-based strategies.The performance of exemplar-based strategies is affected by the specifics of the similarity function and the rate at which similarity declines with distance.The insights from the bias-variance-covariance framework tell us that the success of group judgment depends on strategies the individual members are using (e.g.,low or high variance strategies),what information they are focusing on (e.g.,how much overlap there is between the information they are using),and how the individual assessments are used to reach a group decision (e.g.,averaging or relying on the perceived best member).Using the bias-variance-covariance framework to recognize and analyze these aspects of group judgments can help us understand what factors contribute to successful group decisions in a variety of real world contexts.
其他文献
作者对萨格勒布市医院耳鼻喉科的喉癌病人(1945~1972)及克罗地亚区公共卫生学院的喉癌病人进行流行病学分析。病人来自克罗地亚各地(南斯拉夫西部及南部),本区具有地中海及大
洋葱是人们餐桌上的一种平常蔬菜,由于其味辛、荤,且易胀气,故许多人不喜食。殊不知洋葱有许多保健功能,尤其对老年人的健康具有多方面的呵护作用。 Onion is a common vege
I66新剔除股票技术指标不符合I66要求是利源铝业被剔除出I66的主要原因。近一周内有2家机构调低其2011年盈利预测,其中湘财证券由0.80元调低至0.77元;招商证券则调低至O.75元
一、故障简介一位朋友送来一块熊猫2997型彩电电路板。其故障现象为:有伴音、无光栅,并已有多位维修员上门检修未果。因此,将电路板摘下,让我帮其检修。该机为三洋A6(LA7688
美培育出桔色黄瓜美国农业研究局科学家们已经培育出3个种群的高胡萝卜素黄瓜———桔色黄瓜。桔色深浅在某种程度上因植株、地块或地理位置而异。原载〔美〕《农业研究》Vol43,No
利用吐鲁番秋季小气候提早鉴定西瓜甜瓜杂交率徐介寿安静黄建辉王虎民(新疆昌吉州种子管理站831100)新疆是我国西甜瓜一代杂交种子生产的重要基地。为保证种子质量和及时供种,快速、准
  The prior work has demonstrated that anticipatory negative emotion during the decision process (e.g.,fear,anxiety,and dread) can result in choice deferral.I
会议
我国保险业在2004年底将面临着对外资的全面开放。国内保险业为了应对WTO,提高市场竞争能力,进行了市场化整合。中国大地财产保险股份有限公司就是整合后的新生保险公司。作
一、农业防治桃园早春应搞好开沟排水,防止雨后积水,雨后中耕保墒,深度约8厘米~10厘米。酸性土壤应施用石灰、粘重土增施有机肥料,盐碱地注意挑盐。勿偏施氮肥,适当增施有机肥、磷
编辑同志:我是一个矿区医院的妇产科医生,读了两期《生殖与避孕》杂志后感到,“读者信箱”很能解决我们基层医生在工作中经常碰到的一些实际问题。希望把这个拦目继续办下去