《临床精神医学杂志》先后刊载贾谊诚教授和李植荣主任的文章 ( 1 998,8:1 1 6,368) ,对涉及女精神病人性关系案例进行了详细分析 ,对性自卫能力鉴定的局限性和适用情况作了令人信服的说明 ,然而没有对适用性自卫能力鉴定的情况进行充分讨论。现拟对有关问题提出我们的看法。强 The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry has published articles (1998, 8: 116, 368) about Professor Jia Yicheng and Director Li Zhirong in detail. Cases of sexual relations involving female psychiatric patients were analyzed in detail, and their limitations and applicability were identified The situation was convincingly illustrated, however, without a full discussion of the applicability of the identification of self-defense capabilities. It is our intention to put forward our views on the relevant issues. Strong