论文部分内容阅读
《中学政治教学参考(中旬·初中)》2016年第4期,刊登了周丽萍老师撰写的《以案学法析案明理》一文(以下简称周文),文中周老师选用了“被拐少女反把人贩子拐了”作为教学案例。笔者认为,该案例有以下几个疑点:一是刘慧的行为究竟是不是犯罪行为?二是刘慧是从轻处罚还是减轻处罚?三是刘慧是否应当免除刑罚?四是审理此案的一审法院是哪一级?二审法院是哪一级?五是此案是否适用不公开审理?六是刘慧上诉是由自己决定还是她的父母?一、该案例的几个疑点(一)刘慧的行为究竟是不是
“High School Politics Teaching Reference (middle and junior high school)” 2016 the fourth period, published by Zhou Liping teacher wrote a “Case Study Case Study” article (hereinafter referred to as Zhou Wen), the text selected by Zhou “ Turn traffickers off ”as a teaching case. The author believes that the case has the following doubts: First, Liu Hui’s behavior is not a criminal act? Second, Liu Hui is lighter or mitigated punishment? Third, Liu Hui should be exempt from punishment? Fourth, the trial of the case Which level is the court of first instance? Which level is the level of the court of second instance? Fifth, whether the case is applicable or not? Sixth, is Liu Hui’s appeal decided by her or her parents? Hui’s behavior is not it