Prospective randomized comparison of oral sodium phosphate and polyethylene glycol lavage for colono

来源 :World Journal of Gastroenterology | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:acup
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM: To compare the effectiveness, patient acceptability, and physical tolerability of two oral lavage solutions prior to colonoscopy in a Taiwanese population. METHODS: Eighty consecutive patients were randomized to receive either standard 4 L of polyethylene glycol (PEG) or 90 mL of sodium phosphate (NaP) in a split regimen of two 45 mL doses separated by 12 h, prior to colonoscopic evaluation. The primary endpoint was the percent of subjects who had completed the preparation. Secondary endpoints included colonic cleansing evaluated with an overall assessment and segmental evaluation, the tolerance and acceptability assessed by a self-administered structured questionnaire, and a safety profile such as any unexpected adverse events, electrolyte tests, physical exams, vital signs, and body weights. RESULTS: A significantly higher completion rate was found in the NaP group compared to the PEG group (84.2% vs 27.5%, P<0.001). The amount of fluid suc-tioned was significantly less in patients taking NaP vs PEG (50.13±54.8 cc vs 121.13±115.4 cc, P<0.001), even after controlling for completion of the oral solution (P= 0.031). The two groups showed a comparable overall assessment of bowel preparation with a rate of “good” or “excellent” in 78.9% of patients in the NaP group and 82.5% in PEG group (P = 0.778). Patients taking NaP tended to have significantly better colonic segmental cleansing relative to stool amount observed in the descending (94.7% vs 70%, P = 0.007) and transverse (94.6% vs 74.4%, P = 0.025) colon. Slightly more patients graded the taste of NaP as “good” or “very good” compared to the PEG patients (32.5% vs 12.5%; P = 0.059). Patients’ willingness to take the same preparation in the future was 68.4% in the NaP compared to 75% in the PEG group (P = 0.617). There was a significant increase in serum sodium and a significant decrease in phosphate and chloride levels in NaP group on the day following the colonoscopy without any clinical sequelae. Prolonged (>24 h) hemodynamic changes were also observed in 20-35% subjects of either group. CONCLUSION: Both bowel cleansing agents proved to be similar in safety and effectiveness, while NaP appeared to be more cost-effective. After identifying and excluding patients with potential risk factors, sodium phosphate should become an alternative preparation for patients undergoing elective colonoscopy in the Taiwanese population. METHODS: Eighty consecutive patients were randomized to receive either standard 4 L of polyethylene glycol (PEG) or 90 mL of sodium The primary endpoint was the percent of subjects who had completed the preparation. Secondary endpoints included colonic cleansing evaluated with an overall assessment and segmental evaluation , the tolerance and acceptability assessed by a self-administered structured questionnaire, and a safety profile such as any unexpected adverse events, electrolyte tests, physical exams, vital signs, and body weights. RESULTS: A significantly higher completion rate was found in the NaP group compared to the PEG group (84.2% vs 27.5%, P <0.001). The amount of fluid suc-tioned was significantly less in patie nts taking NaP vs. PEG (50.13 ± 54.8 cc vs 121.13 ± 115.4 cc, P <0.001) even after controlling for completion of the oral solution (P = 0.031). The two groups showed a comparable overall assessment of bowel preparation with a rate of “good” or “excellent” in 78.9% of patients in the NaP group and 82.5% in PEG group (P = 0.778). Patients taking NaP tended to have significantly better colonic segmental cleansing relative to stool amount observed in the descending (94.7% vs 70%, P = 0.007) and transverse (94.6% vs 74.4%, P = 0.025) colon. Slightly more patients graded the taste of NaP as “good ” or “very good ” compared to Patients’ willingness to take the same preparation in the future was 68.4% in the NaP compared to 75% in the PEG group (P = 0.617). There was a significant increase in serum sodium and a significant decrease in phosphate and chloride levels in NaP group on the day following the colonoscopy without any clinical sequelae. Pr olCONCLUSION: Both bowel cleansing agents proved to be similar in safety and effectiveness, while NaP was found to be more cost-effective. After identifying and excluding patients with potential risk factors, sodium phosphate should become an alternative preparation for patients undergoing elective colonoscopy in the Taiwanese population.
其他文献
政策引导和扶持,以及大量资金投入电子商务市场将促使国内电子商务企业投融资新高潮的到来。作为电子商务的一个重要组成部分,网络营销正日渐被人们认同和接受“如果十年前做
全称为1956年式冲锋枪,是建国后我国仿造的苏制系列武器之一。其原型是原苏联枪械大师卡拉什尼科夫设计的AK-47自动步枪,是世界上唯一装有可折叠枪刺的自动步枪;56-1式和56-2
AIM: To determine the fasting plasma carnitine ester in patients with celiac disease. METHODS: We determined the fasting plasma carnitine ester profile using ES
绿色开花植物都要经过开花、结果、产生种子的过程,来繁殖后代。在开花植物中,除了豌豆、小麦、水稻、高粱等少数靠自花传粉来形成果实和种子外,大多数植物都要靠异花传粉来
TO THE EDITOR Fenofibrate is a member of such fibrate class agents as bezafibrate and it work as a ligand of PPARa, and also shows a potent triglyceride-lowerin
一、理念引导造氛围集团公司领导提出了“全体职工培训一遍”的要求,各子公司、单位都成立了以党政领导为组长、培训工作分管领导为副组长、由相关科室负责人员组成的安全培
最近,住在重庆动物园雉(zhì)科笼里的动物们可高兴坏了。因为今年就是12年轮一次的鸡年,凡是和鸡相关的事物都火啦!雉科笼里好多动物的名字都带“鸡”字,你说它们能不激动吗
在20世纪70年代初期,南斯拉夫引进了苏联出口型T-72M主战坦克,南斯拉夫国营兵工厂在此基础上稍加改进后,于1982年制造出了首辆M-84主战坦克,1984年开始批量生产并装备部队,该
儿子正上高一,青春的荷尔蒙在他体内开始积蓄荡漾,人也显得越来越叛逆了,老师根本管不了:比如唱一些粗俗的歌,说一些愤青的话;平白无故在牛仔裤上戳几个大洞;把好端端的黑发
AIM: To investigate the anti-ischemic properties of perfluorochemical emulsion “perftoran” in mesenteric region. METHODS: Experiments were conducted on 146 no