《南岳唱酬集》旧署朱熹编,误收现象十分严重。该书现存明弘治刻本、清抄本。南京图书馆藏清抄本有明天顺时邓淮序、林果跋,表明天顺本渊源有绪。本文考知邓淮登进士第的年代,推断天顺本序跋当是伪作,而弘治本邓淮序称《唱酬集》是由他从朱熹、张拭文集中“摘”出即重辑的,才是事实。盖重辑时草草成书,故编纂质量甚差。 “Nanyue singing set” Old Department Zhu Xi series, the phenomenon of wrongly received is very serious. The existing book Ming Hongzhi engraved, Qing Ban Ben. Nanjing library possession clear transcript Tomorrow Shunghuai sequence, apricot forest Postscript, indicating that there is a thread of Tianshun this. This article examines the age of the predecessors of Huai Deng Deng Jinshi, concludes that the order of postscript when Tianshun is a fake, and Hongzhi Ben-Huai sequence called “pay set” by him from the Zhu Xi, Zhang Xuan Wen concentrated “pick” that is, re-editing, is the fact. Cover heavy series of time into a book, so the quality of editing is very poor.