先前笔者透过佘嘉惠《临罗两峰鬼趣图》上发现的裕瑞书迹与印章,推判《枣窗闲笔》应就是裕瑞手录的,但相关论争并未因此止歇。本文即根据学界新近在《遂初堂未定稿》《梅石犬戏》《蝶仙图》上所发现的裕瑞序跋、题诗与钤印,强有力地回应以《枣窗闲笔》乃伪书的质疑。 Earlier, the author found out that “Jujube window freelance pen” should be recorded by Yu Rui through the records and seals of Yu Rui found on She Jiahui’s “Pro Luo Erfeng Ghost Map”, but the relevant controversy did not stop there. This article is based on the scholars recently found in the “Suizutang is not finalized,” “Meishan dog show,” “Butterfly Xian Figure” found on the Yu Rui preface and epilogue and imprint, a strong response to “jujube window idle pen” is a false book Questioning