论文部分内容阅读
许霆案反映了在机会面前,人性有经不住诱惑的弱点,但司法不能肯定或者张扬人性的这一弱点,否则,势必造成善恶价值观的混淆。当然,许霆案发生是基于一定机遇发生的,尽管人们完全有理由期待许霆在ATM机出错时,不要乘虚而入、重复取款,但现实生活中确实有相当一部分人出于人性贪婪的一面,经不住类似的偶然诱惑,对其适法期待可能性有所减弱,可以考虑减轻处罚。这也是重审改判的一个重要原因,也充分体现了法律之外的人情和人性考量。
Xu Ting case reflects the weakness that human beings can not resist temptation before the opportunity, but the judicial affair can not affirm or publicize this weakness of human nature, otherwise it is bound to cause the confusion of values of good and evil. Of course, the occurrence of the Xu Ting occurred based on certain opportunities, although people have reason to expect Xu Ting ATM machine error, do not take advantage of, repeated withdrawals, but in real life does have a considerable part of the human nature of greed on the side, Do not live a similar accidental temptation to reduce the likelihood of their legitimate expectations, you can consider mitigating punishment. This is also an important reason for reviewing and reshuffling the sentence, which fully reflects the consideration of human nature and humanity outside the law.