《古诗赏鉴四题》(《名作欣赏》2006年6月号上半月刊)读来莫名其妙,不知所云,作者数落他人“捕风捉影”、“言之无据”,“没有像样一点儿的文学批评”,其实这些用来评价该文,倒是挺合适的。四首唐诗的“赏鉴”,皆扔弃原作,亦不顾及诗人当时处境,想入非非“赏鉴”,此乃极不好文 “Four Poems Appreciation Tour” (“Masterpiece Appreciation,” June 2006 issue of the first half of the monthly magazine) read inexplicable, unintelligible, the author countless others “catching the eye”, “no evidence”, “no decent literary criticism” In fact, these are used to evaluate the article, it touches very appropriate. The four “Tangjian” appreciation, are abandoned the original, regardless of the poet was the situation at the time, like non-“appreciation”, this is very bad text