民事审判权作用范围的类型化分析——从审判权对社会干预的角度

来源 :广西政法管理干部学院学报 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:wangshuanghong2009
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
当事人对审判权在承担社会冲突解决方面的能力期望过高,这与审判权干预社会的依据不足存在矛盾,由此导致司法实践中法院对某些纠纷是否应予立案受理缺乏明确客观的依据,纠纷不被受理的当事人对法院存在误解,学术界对此也颇有诟病,司法实务界也比较头疼。针对民事审判权作用范围界定标准不客观导致的问题,学术界除探讨在立案审查方式上进行改革外,主要仍是从传统的抽象法律思维角度试图对概念进行完善,并提出以“诉的利益”为标准界定民事审判权的作用范围。但是,从抽象思维角度对概念的完善仍存在其难以避免的不明确性。本文根据司法实践中确需考虑民事审判权作用范围界定标准的实际情况以及法律发展的规律,尝试运用个案类型化的思维方法去解决民事审判权作用范围界定标准不明确的问题。从个案类型化的权威性以及法律适用的统一性角度出发,在个案类型化的具体实施方面,笔者建议在民商审判线分两级实行新类型案件报告制度。本文还对笔者承办的涉及离婚纠纷但被告下落不明、环境侵权纠纷以及关注的起诉要求继续履行合伙协议的纠纷等个案,尝试运用类型化的方式进行分析。 There is a contradiction between the parties’ expectation on the ability of judicial power to undertake the social conflict resolution, which is contradicted by the fact that the judicial power interferes with the social basis. As a result, the court lacks a clear and objective basis for whether or not some disputes should be accepted in judicial practice. The parties to the disputes are not misunderstood about the courts. The academic circles are also quite criticized for it. The judiciary circles are also more headache. In view of the problem that the criterion of the scope of civil jurisdiction is not objectively caused, the academic circles, apart from discussing the reform on the way of filing the case, still try to perfect the concept from the perspective of the traditional abstract legal thinking and propose that “ Interest ”as the standard definition of the scope of civil jurisdiction. However, the perfection of concepts from the perspective of abstract thinking still has its unavoidable uncertainty. This paper tries to use the case-type thinking method to solve the problem that the definition of the scope of the civil jurisdiction is not clear according to the fact that the judicial practice does need to consider the actual situation of defining the scope of the role of civil jurisdiction and the law of legal development. From the perspective of individuality of cases and the uniformity of applicable law, in the concrete implementation of case types, the author suggests that a new type of case reporting system be implemented in two stages in civil and commercial trial lines. This article also tries to use the type of analysis to the case that the author contravenes divorce disputes but the defendant’s whereabouts are unknown, the environmental infringement dispute and the concern about the prosecution request to continue the dispute of the partnership agreement.
其他文献
刘海明在《环球时报》撰文认为,目前,对个人心理素养、文化素养、知识素养的提升已成社会共以,但对爱国素养的认识不足,没有引起重视。一个公民,若是其爱圈素养“营养不良”,在特定
审讯贪贿犯罪嫌疑入是审讯入员与犯罪嫌疑入之间的心理战,从一定意义上讲,是一场十分复杂尖锐的心理交锋。突破涉嫌贪贿犯罪嫌疑人是反贪案件的基础环节,审讯人员与犯罪嫌疑人之
省委关于在全省党员、干部中开展马克思主义唯物论无神论教育的通知下发后,全省各级党组织和广大党员、干部积极开展了学习教育活动,收到了好的效果。但是,据了解,两论教育还存在
期刊
中国机械工程学会近日下发“机学组[2017]39号”文件批复,同意中国机械工程学会流体传动与控制分会增聘哈尔滨工业大学姜继海教授为分会第六届委员会委员、常务委员。
大雪纷扬时,人们不由想起千里冰封万里雪飘的北国;山花烂熳时,人们又怎能忘记山丹丹盛开的革命圣地延安!西包铁路与候黄铁路有一个交汇的地点,这个交汇点叫负李河火车站。
7月21日下午,陕西省人大常委会就2010年陕西省财政决算报告举行专题询问,陕西省财政厅领导班子成员到会接受省人大常委会组成人员询问。在两个小时的询问中,11位陕西省人大常
针对RT-flex系列二冲程低速柴油机配套燃油喷射系统存在的问题,基于液压伺服控制原理提出一种新型船用高压共轨燃油喷射伺服控制系统,该系统采用液压位置闭环系统控制高压重油
随着国有企业改革的深化和社会主义市场经济的发展,应遵循江总书记“三个代表”重要思想和与时俱进、开拓创新的要求,着眼于建立和完善与社会主义市场经济体制和现代企业制度
期刊
期刊