2月16日《中国青年报》的科普小议——“长江油轮爆炸有无抢救上的失误?”中提到1月2日武汉长江“63040”号油驳火灾扑救中“用水去浇正在燃烧的4800吨原油,至少是常识上的失误。”这里,我们且不去谈是否存在燃烧的4800吨原油和是否用水去浇了燃烧的油火,仅以“油火能不能用水来救”这一点谈些不同看法。显然,因为在此次扑救过程中发生了意外的爆炸,火灾扑救被迫中止,指挥员的完整意图和灭火方案未能得到体现。对此作者是不了 February 16 “China Youth Daily” popular discussion - “Yangtze River tanker explosion rescue?” Mentioned in the January 2 Wuhan Yangtze River “63040 ” oil barge fire fighting in the “At least it is a commonsense mistake to use water to pour the 4,800 tons of crude oil that is burning.” Here we will not talk about the existence of 4,800 tons of crude oil, Fire can not use water to save "This talk about some different views. Obviously, because of the accidental explosion during the rescue, fire fighting was suspended and the commander’s complete intentions and fire fighting plan were not reflected. This author can not