论文部分内容阅读
《全唐诗》、《全唐诗补编》共计收录张旭诗歌十首。今据考证,其中有七首与宋人重出,另三首也在疑似之间。造成这种重收互见的原因,可能在于最初辑录者对书画作品中诗歌之误判。与其说洪迈误判了张旭、蔡襄二人的诗歌,毋宁说他误判了他们的书法作品;与其说洪迈在辑录诗歌时出了问题,毋宁说是在书画鉴定上出了问题。而陶宗仪、文徵明等人的题跋鉴定,又误导了我们今天对所谓《张长史缣素四诗帖》的辑佚工作。张旭伪诗现象,不是孤例,在唐宋时期的总集、别集编纂中,往往有之。
“Full Tang Poetry”, “Full Tang Poetry Supplement” contains a total of ten poems Zhang Xu poetry. Today, according to research, of which seven were re-born with the Song, the other three are also suspected. Reasons for this mutual repercussion may lie in the initial editors’ misjudgment of poetry in calligraphy and painting. Instead Hongmai misjudged Zhang Xu and Cai Xiang’s two poems, rather, he misjudged their calligraphic works. Instead of saying that Hongmai had a problem in compiling poetry, it was rather a problem in calligraphy and painting appraisal . The identification of Tao Zongyi and Wen Zhengming et al. Also mislead us to the lost work of the so-called “Zhang Chang Shi Su Su Si Poetry” today. Zhang Xu pseudo-poetry phenomenon, not a solitary case, in the Tang and Song Dynasties of the total episode, do not set compilation, often have.