我们阅读和座谈了人民司法第9期发表的关于区分两类不同性质矛盾的三篇文章后,一致认为这几篇文章对两类不同性质矛盾的分析是比较全面的,论点基本上是正确的,对审判工作的指导意义很大,但是其中有个别地方阐述的不够明确,特提出不成熟意见与作者商榷,如有错误,请作者和同志们批评指正。“在刑事案件中如何区分两类矛盾的意见”一文中,作者杨达群、沈关生二同志对判定案件性质和量刑的关系问题上,提出:“判定案件性质是分清敌我界限的问题,量刑 After reading and discussing the three articles published by People’s Judicature No. 9 on distinguishing two types of contradictions of different nature, we all agreed that the analysis of these two types of contradictions of different nature is more comprehensive and the arguments are basically correct . However, some of these areas are not clear enough in their elaboration. They have put forward some immature opinions to discuss with the authors. If there is any mistake, they should be criticized and corrected by the authors and comrades. In his article “How to Discriminate Two Kinds of Contradictions in Criminal Cases,” Comrade Yang Daqun and Shen Guansheng, two comrades, raised the issue of determining the nature of the case and the relationship between sentencing and punishment: "