论文部分内容阅读
余嘉锡所著《四库提要辨证》是对《四库全书总目》研究的重要成果。此书对《四库总目》中的490余篇提要进行了辨证,提出不少宝贵意见,但也存在一些可以进一步讨论的问题。仅就《四库提要辨证·神僧传》条的考证思路、论据等进行讨论,认为余嘉锡先生从目录学角度讨论《神僧传》的撰者问题,其论述过程不够严谨,所提供论据存在问题,不能直接指向结论,因此,所得结论很难令人信服。从《神僧传》版本源流角度入手,用直接论据使《神僧传》撰者问题更加明确、所得结论《神僧传》为明成祖所撰集更具说服力。
YU Jia-xin’s “Siku diary dialectical syndrome” is an important achievement of the study of “Sikuquanshu”. The book dialecticized more than 490 articles in the “Siku Headbook” and put forward many valuable suggestions, but there are also some issues that can be further discussed. Only on the “Siku diary Syndromes, Biography of God monk” article thinking, arguments and other discussions, that Yu Jiaxi from the perspective of bibliography “God monk Biography” the author’s question, the discussion of the process is not rigorous rigor, the argument provided by the existence of problems , Can not point directly to the conclusion, therefore, the conclusion is difficult to convince. Starting from the source and origin of the version of “Seng monk”, the thesis made the issue of “monk monk biography” more straightforward by using direct argument. The conclusion “monk monk” is even more persuasive by Ming Chengzu.