论文部分内容阅读
2016年12月2日,最高人民法院第二巡回法庭对聂树斌故意杀人、强奸妇女再审案公开宣判,宣告撤销原审判决,改判聂树斌无罪。12月14日,聂树斌家人委托律师向河北省高级人民法院递交了《刑事国家赔偿申请书》,其中提出7项赔偿申请,金额近1400万元,其中1200万元为精神损害抚慰金。关于赔偿金,舆论普遍认为,给再多钱也换不回聂树斌的命,他的家人提出再高的索赔金额也不过分。当然,千万级别的精神损害抚慰金恐怕很难获得全部支持。不久前,呼格吉勒图案中的国家赔偿金是206万元,包含了100万元精神损害抚慰金。聂树斌案沉冤20多年,可以想象,作为“杀人犯”的家人,在这段时间里承受了多少羞辱、折磨。为了申冤,他们遇到了多少阻挠和委屈。从这个角度来说,精神损害赔偿宜多不宜少。不过,在我国的国家赔偿案件里,更侧重对名誉的恢复、正义的伸张,主要是精神性的修复,在物质上往往显得比较“节约”。但是,从社会效果来说,该花
On December 2, 2016, the Second Circuit Tribunal of the Supreme People’s Court publicly announced Nie Shu-bin’s intentional murder and rape of women’s retrial, announcing the acquittal of the trial and committing Nie Shu-bin innocence. On December 14, Nie Shubin’s family entrusted a lawyer to submit an Application for Criminal State Compensation to the Higher People’s Court of Hebei Province, of which 7 applications for compensation were made, amounting to nearly 14 million yuan, of which 12 million yuan were mental damages. On the compensation, public opinion generally believes that Nye Shubin’s life will not be changed for more money. His family’s claim of a further high amount of money is not excessive. Of course, tens of thousands of levels of mental damage soars gold is probably difficult to get full support. Not long ago, the national compensation in Hugg Gillet’s logo was 2.06 million yuan, including 1 million yuan of mental damage solatium. Nie Shubin case of injustice 20 years, you can imagine, as “murderer ” family, how much humiliation, torture during this time. How many obstructions and grievances they have encountered for redress. From this perspective, compensation for moral damage should not be less. However, in China’s state compensation cases, more emphasis is placed on the restoration of reputation, the extension of justice, and mainly the spiritual restoration, which often appears to be materially “saving”. However, from the social effect, the flower