论文部分内容阅读
《当代中国史研究》编辑部：贵刊2006年第4期发表了韩亚光先生的札记《“三分天灾,七分人祸”说考辨》(以下简称“韩文”)。札记不长,但通过对刘少奇1962年初在扩大的中央工作会议讲话中“三分天灾,七分人祸”说法的考辨认为,这一说法只是刘少奇针对某些局部地区困难情况所做的分析,并不适用于全国范围困难成因的概括。对于韩文的这一观点,本人不敢苟同,觉得有进一步考辨的必要。因为这一说法不仅关系到如何概括造成三年困难时期(1959～1961年)成因的问题,而且牵涉到对这一时段历史如何评价的问题。
“Contemporary Chinese History Research” Editorial Department: No.4 issue 2006Year published notes of Mr. Han Yaguang “The examination and discussion of” one thirds of natural disasters and seven human beings “(hereinafter referred to as” Korean “). There is not a long record, but through the examination of Liu Shao-chi’s argument that ”one-third of natural disasters and seven man-made disasters" in his speech at the enlarged Central Work Conference in early 1962 argues that this is only an analysis made by Liu Shaoqi against the difficult circumstances in some local areas, It does not apply to the cause of the nationwide summary of the causes. For this view of Korean, I do not agree, think there is a need for further examination. Because this not only concerns how to summarize the causes of the causes of the three-year difficult period (1959-1961), but also how to evaluate the history of the period.