学术研究必须建立在真实材料与“求真”的目的性上,“红楼梦研究”也应该以事实为基础,以文本为根本依据。而刘心武的“秦学”研究却是建立在捏造事实的基础上。并且,他的论证都是以臆测、牵强附会来展开话题,因此,可以说,这样的学术是“伪学术”。所谓“秦学”,就是一种“伪红学”。而以“秦学”为中心展开的一系列“学术”活动,功利主义是极强的。 Academic research must be based on the true material and the goal of “seeking truth”. The study of A Dream of Red Mansions should also be based on facts and based on texts. And Liu Xinwu’s “Qin study” is based on fabricated facts. And his arguments are all based on conjecture and far-fetched questions, so we can say that such an academic is “pseudo-academic.” The so-called “Qin school” is a kind of “pseudo-redology.” While a series of “academic” activities centered on “Qin Learning” are utilitarianism is extremely strong.