《名作欣赏》2016年第三、四期,连载了徐庆全、胡学常、商昌宝三位先生有关历史视域下文学史与文学创作的谈话。谈话的内容、方式、思路,谈话背后体现出的某种心态与作风,以及此后看到部分专家学者的点评,都令笔者深感不安。故不揣浅陋,仅就文学史话题,撰文一篇,以期抛砖引玉,获得各路方家的指点与批评。 “Masterpieces Appreciation” 2016 The third and fourth installments contain a series of interviews with Xu Qingquan, Hu Xuechang and Shang Changbao about the history of literature and literary creation from a historical perspective. The contents, ways, ideas and conversations of the conversation reflected some mentality and work style, and afterwards, some experts and scholars’ comments made me deeply disturbed. Therefore, it does not pretend to be simple and crude. It only writes an article on the topic of literary history with a view to giving pointers and criticisms to various parties.