学术界对西夏蕃、汉并存官制的研究,主要有两种观点:一、认为是两套官制。持此意见的人在解释其出现背景时又有两种不同说法:一是认为蕃、汉并存官制乃是受西夏奴隶制、和封建制两种不同经济的制约而产生的,另一种则认为“此举颇类辽制,官分南北”,是吸取了辽的一些经验和作法。二、认为是一套官制。也有两种不同的解释:一说认为是为 Academics on the Western Xia Fan, Han coexistence of official system, there are two main points: First, that is two sets of official system. The people who hold this opinion have two different opinions after explaining their background: First, they think that the coexistence of the official and the Han government was caused by the constraints of Xixia slavery and feudalism, while the other They thought that “this measure is quite similar to that of the Liao Dynasty, and that the official branch is north and south” draws some experience and practices from Liao. Second, that is a set of official system. There are two different explanations: one is considered as