这场争论在外贸外资上的反映,是有人提出外贸依存比较大、外资垄断市场等等。讨论最激烈的,就是两税合一问题。这个争论,已经不仅仅是学界争论,已成为政府部门之间的争论。大家一直认为商务部反对合一。我这里作一个澄清,我参加过商务部的若干会议,从来没有谁反对过两税合一的建议。我个人的看法,两税合一这个命题本身,从长远看肯定是对的,给各类企业一个平等的竞争环境。但要考虑几个问题。大家知道,国际资本流 The debate on this foreign investment in foreign investment reflects that some people have pointed to the relatively large dependence on foreign trade and the monopoly of foreign investment in the market. The most intense discussion is the integration of the two taxes. This controversy has not only debated the academic community, but has become a controversy among government departments. Everyone has always believed that the Ministry of Commerce opposes unity. I will make a clarification here. I attended a number of meetings of the Ministry of Commerce. No one ever opposed the proposal of integrating the two taxes. My own view, the proposition that the two taxes are one and the same, is certainly correct in the long run and gives all kinds of enterprises an equal competitive environment. But consider a few questions. We all know that international capital flow