过去几年中有人指责新歌剧是“话剧加唱”,根本否定新歌剧这种艺术形式,认为歌剧和话剧水火不相容,在它们中间划了一道鸿沟。到底新歌剧是不是“话剧加唱”?“话剧加唱”是否就一定坏,总要弄清楚才好。指责新歌剧为“话剧加唱”的理由大约有两类:1、新歌剧的形式不完整:有唱又有白,“白”跟话剧一样,唱和话剧里的插曲差不多;没有统一的贯串的音乐,没有完美的咏叹调及刻划人物和环境的音乐描写。因此,所谓“新歌剧”实在不能算什么“歌剧”.2、新歌剧的形式不完整:唱没有一定的曲牌、板眼,“白”没有韵味,唱跟小调或流行歌曲差不多;又没有优美的身段,也没有够劲的表情。因此,叫做 In the past few years, some people accused the new opera of “singing and singing” and simply denied this form of art as a new opera. They considered that opera and drama were incompatible and a gap was drawn between them. In the end of the new opera is not “play plus singing”? “Drama plus singing” is certainly bad, we must always find out. There are two reasons for accusing the New Opera of “singing and singing”: 1. The forms of the new opera are incomplete: the singing and the writing are white, and the writing of “white” is the same as drama. The singing is almost the same as the episode in the drama; Music, perfect aria and musical depictions of characters and surroundings. Therefore, the so-called “New Opera” really can not be regarded as “opera.” 2, the new opera in the form of incomplete: there is no certain song, plate, “white” no charm, singing with minor or popular songs; The figure, there is no strong enough expression. So called