近读《文学自由谈》九七年第五期上刘心武写的《重读〈钢铁是怎样炼成的〉》（以下简称《重读》）一文后，感到有话要说。心武先生在《重读》对《钢铁是怎样炼成的》先是赞扬一番，然后又大兴讨伐，发出种种非难。诚然，任何优秀的作品都有不足之处，对其进行科学的评论是... Having read the article on “Freedom of Literature,” on the fifth issue of 1997, Liu Xinwu wrote “How to Make Iron and Steel” (hereinafter referred to as “Re-reading”). In the “reread” on “how the steel is made of” first praised about something, and then Daxing crusade, issued a variety of non-difficult. Admittedly, any good work has its own shortcomings, and its scientific commentary is ...