张国焘在《我的回忆》中说,一、四方面军在懋功会合后,举行中央军事委员会会议。会上就在何地建立革命根据地问题展开争论,他主张西进计划,认为这既可“避战”,又可“争取较长时间的休息”(第三册第二三三页)。他还说,参加会议的人,大多表示应避开战争,找一个能有较长时间休养生息的地方。因此,他们“也没有否定我的西进意见”(同上)。历史事实果真如此吗? In his “Memories,” Zhang Guotao said that the first and the fourth armies held a meeting of the Central Military Commission after the meeting of Mao Gong. At the meeting, he argued about the establishment of a revolutionary base in any place. He advocated the Westernization Plan as “averting the war” and “for a longer period of rest” (Book III, p. 233). He also said that most of the participants in the conference said that they should avoid the war and find a place where they can have a longer time to recuperate. Therefore, they “did not deny my comments on the Westward Development” (ibid.). Historical facts really so?