A comparison between different methods for determining grain distribution in coarse channel beds

来源 :International Journal of Sediment Research | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:wjbbio
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
The determination of grain size distribution in alluvial channels plays a crucial role in understanding fluvial dynamics and processes(e.g.,hydraulic resistance,sediment transport and erosion,and habitat suitability).However,to determine an accurate distribution,tremendous field efforts are often required.Traditionally,the grain size distribution of channel beds have been obtained by manually counting a set of randomly selected stones(the “pebble count”).Based on this elementary principle,many authors have proposed different adaptations to overcome weaknesses and problems with the original method;with the development of digital technology,photographic methods have been developed in order to significantly reduce the time spent in the field.Two of these “image-assisted” methods include Automated Grain Sizing,ACS,and Manual Photo Sieving,MPS.In this study,AGS and MPS were applied under ideal laboratory conditions,to be used as reference,and in two field conditions with different degrees of difficulty in terms of visual determination of the grain size distribution;these included an artificial unlined channel and two natural mountainous streams.The results were compared with those obtained with the pebble-count method.In general,strong agreement between the methods was found when they were applied under favorable conditions( “the laboratory”),and the differences between the imageassisted and pebble count methods were similar to those found in previous studies.Despite being more time consuming,MPS was deemed preferable to AGS when conditions are not optimal;in these cases,the time spent on image elaboration significantly increased in the AGS method(approximately three-fold),but the estimation error of the median grain size decreased by approximately 37%.The use of imageassisted analysis has proven to be robust for characterizing sediment in watercourse beds and reducing fieldwork time,but because field conditions can significantly affect the accuracy of results,the method choice must be carefully considered. The determination of grain size distribution in alluvial channels plays a critical role in understanding fluvial dynamics and processes (eg, hydraulic resistance, sediment transport and erosion, and habitat suitability) .However, to determine an accurate distribution, tremendous field efforts are often required. Traditionally, the grain size distribution of channel beds have been obtained by manually counting a set of randomly selected stones (the “pebble count”). Based on this elementary principle, many authors have proposed different adaptations to overcome weaknesses and problems with the original method; with the development of digital technology, photographic methods have been developed in order to significantly reduce the time spent in the field. Two of these “image-assisted” methods include Automated Grain Sizing, ACS, and Manual Photo Sieving, MPS. This study, AGS and MPS were applied under ideal laboratory conditions, to be used as reference, and in two field conditions with different degre es of difficulty in terms of visual determination of the grain size distribution; these included an artificial unlined channel and two natural mountainous streams.The results were compared with those obtained the pebble-count method.In general, strong agreement between the methods was found when they were applied under favorable conditions ( “the laboratory ”), and the differences between the imageassisted and pebble count methods were similar to those found in previous studies not optimal; in these cases, the time spent on image elaboration significantly increased in the AGS method (approximately three-fold), but the estimation error of the median grain size decreased by approximately 37%. The use of imageassisted analysis has proven to be robust for characterizing sediment in watercourse beds and reducing fieldwork time, but because field conditions can significantly affect the accuracy of results, themethod choice must be carefully considered.
其他文献
从美国心理学家斯佩里发现人类左右脑功能的不对称性以来,音乐与智力的关系成为世界各国相关领域学者探讨的热点问题。斯佩里称负责形象思维功能的右脑为“音乐脑”,称负责抽
期刊
复合材料能提供比金属材料更好的结构性能,但飞机的选材需要十分慎重,飞机设计师在采用先进的复合材料制造零部件时,往往忽略了制造成本,特别是与新材料使用有关的维修性能、
期刊
所谓邻里交互空间,就是邻里或社区中的任何空间构建,是能够反映和承载邻里关系的空间,是居民能与他人共同使用和停留,并且发生交往行为的空间。作为私密与公共空间之间的过渡空间
期刊
该文从挂篮荷载计算、施工流程、支座及临时固结施工、挂篮安装及试验、合拢段施工、模板制作安装、钢筋安装、混凝土的浇筑及养生、测量监控等方面人手,介绍了S226海滨大桥
《婴戏图》是中国古代绘画的一类题材,美术史一般将其归入风俗画类。从史料记载可知,从魏晋时期开始,中国古代的人物画家就将儿童形象纳入人物画中,到了隋唐,画家就着力从独特的视
期刊
期刊