《炎黄春秋》2004年第3期刊出笔者所写《再谈项英与皖南事变》,第4期又刊出甘惜分所写《从大局看皖南事变》(以下简称《甘文》),两文的观点是不同的。《炎黄春秋》发表不同观点的文章,有助于读者从对比中明辨是非。我们认为,观点可以不同,但史实必须准确。《甘文》中的观点有的 “Yanhuang Chunqiu” 2004 the third period published by the author wrote “talk about Xiang Ying and the Southern Anhui Incident”, the fourth issue also published Ganxi sub-office to write “from the overall situation in South Anhui incident” (hereinafter referred to as “Gan Wen”), The two views are different. “Yanhuang Chunqiu” published articles from different points of view, help readers distinguish between right and wrong from the contrast. We think the views can be different, but the facts must be accurate. There are some ideas in “wen-wen”