金人王若虚在其《滹南诗话》中对黄庭坚大加斥责,这既与当时的诗坛风气有关,也与王若虚本人的诗歌观念有关。而这种斥责更来源于王若虚审视黄庭坚诗歌时采用的双重标准,主要集中体现在其主观引用前人评论、苛刻要求黄诗及歪曲黄诗成就等方面。这不仅造成对黄诗的过分贬低,也不利于指导人们正确评价诗歌作品。 Huang Renjian, the golden person of Wang Ruoxu, rebukes Huang Tingjian in his “poem of Taonan”, which is not only related to the poetic ethos of that time, but also related to Wang Ruoxue’s own poetry conception. This kind of reprimand derives more from the double standards adopted by Wang Rujian when he examines the poems of Huang Tingjian, mainly reflected in the subjective quotation of his predecessors’ comments, the harsh demands on the Huangshi Poems and the distortion of Huangshi’s achievements. This not only leads to the excessive devaluation of Huang’s poems, but also to the guidance of people’s correct evaluation of poetry.