A prospective trial of volumetric intensity-modulated arc therapy vs conventional intensity modulate

来源 :World Journal of Clinical Oncology | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:gaoxiaoyu123
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM: To prospectively compare volumetric intensitymodulated arc therapy(VMAT) and conventional intensity-modulated radiation therapy(IMRT) in coverage of planning target volumes and avoidance of multiple organs at risk(OARs) in patients undergoing definitive chemoradiotherapy for advanced(stage Ⅲ or Ⅳ)squamous cell cancer of the head and neck. METHODS: Computed tomography scans of 20 patients with advanced tumors of the larynx, naso-, oroand hypopharynx were prospectively planned using IMRT(7 field) and VMAT using two arcs. Calculated doses to planning target volume(PTV) and OAR were compared between IMRT and VMAT plans. Dose-volume histograms(DVH) were utilized to obtain calculated doses to PTV and OAR, including parotids, cochlea,spinal cord, brainstem, anterior tongue, pituitary and brachial plexus. DVH’s for all structures were compared between IMRT and VMAT plans. In addition the planswere compared for dose conformity and homogeneity. The final treatment plan was chosen by the treating radiation oncologist. RESULTS: VMAT was chosen as the ultimate plan in 18 of 20 patients(90%) because the plans were thought to be otherwise clinically equivalent. The IMRT plan was chosen in 2 of 20 patients because the VMAT plan produced concentric irradiation of the cord which was not overcome even with an avoidance structure. For all patients, VMAT plans had a lower number of average monitor units on average(MU = 542.85) than IMRT plans(MU = 1612.58)(P < 0.001). Using the conformity index(CI), defined as the 95% isodose volume divided by the PTV, the IMRT plan was more conformal with a lower conformity index(CI = 1.61) than the VMAT plan(CI = 2.00)(P = 0.003). Dose homogeneity, as measured by average standard deviation of dose distribution over the PTV, was not different with VMAT(1.45 Gy) or IMRT(1.73 Gy)(P = 0.069). There were no differences in sparing organs at risk.CONCLUSION: In this prospective study, VMAT plans were chosen over IMRT 90% of the time. Compared to IMRT, VMAT plans used only one third of the MUs, had shorter treatment times, and similar sparing of OAR. Overall, VMAT provided similar dose homogeneity but less conformity in PTV irradiation compared to IMRT. This difference in conformity was not clinically significant. AIM: To prospectively compare volumetric intensity modulatedodulated arc therapy (VMAT) and conventional intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) in coverage of planning target volumes and avoidance of multiple organs at risk (OARs) in patients undergoing definitive chemoradiotherapy for advanced ) squamous cell cancer of the head and neck. METHODS: Computed tomography scans of 20 patients with advanced tumors of the larynx, naso-, oro and hypopharynx were prospectively planned using IMRT (7 field) and VMAT using two arcs. Calculated doses to planning target volume (PTV) and OAR were compared between IMRT and VMAT plans. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) were utilized to obtain calculated doses to PTV and OAR, including parotids, cochlea, spinal cord, brainstem, anterior tongue, pituitary and brachial plexus. DVH’s for all structures were compared between IMRT and VMAT plans. In addition the Planswere compared for dose conformity and homogeneity. The final treatment plan was chosen by the treated radiation oncologist. RESULTS: VMAT was chosen as the ultimate plan in 18 of 20 patients (90%) because the plans were thought to be otherwise clinically equivalent. The IMRT plan was chosen in 2 of 20 patients because of VMAT plan produced concentric irradiation of the cord which was not stuck even with an avoidance structure. For all patients, VMAT plans had a lower number of average monitor units on average (MU = 542.85) than IMRT plans (MU = 1612.58) (P <0.001). Using the conformity index (CI), defined as the 95% isodose volume divided by the PTV, the IMRT plan was more conformal with a lower conformity index (CI = 1.61) than the VMAT plan (CI = 2.00) homogeneity, as measured by average standard deviation of dose distribution over the PTV, was not different with VMAT (1.45 Gy) or IMRT (1.73 Gy) (P = 0.069). There were no differences in sparing organs at risk. prospective study, VMAT plans were chosen over IMRT 90% of the time. Compared to IMR T, V.MAT plans used only one third of the MUs, had shorter treatment times, and similar sparing of OAR. Overall, VMAT provided similar dose homogeneity but less conformity in PTV irradiation compared to IMRT. This difference in conformity was not clinically significant.
其他文献
骨肉瘤是一种好发于青少年的高度恶性肿瘤,研究表明骨肉瘤的术后复发和转移是影响患者预后的主要因素。肿瘤血管的生长无疑是肿瘤发生侵袭和转移的重要因素。血管对于肿瘤的
本文以河套灌区的农田防护林为研究对象,通过对所选农田防护林背风面距林带不同距离处小麦株高、穗长、每穗小穗数、穗粒数、第一节间长、穗下节间长、千粒重和产量的测定以及林网内小麦与对照小麦生育期的平行对比观测,研究了农田防护林的增产效益。结果如下:河套灌区的农田防护林能够增加小麦的产量,所选三条样线小麦的平均产量均显著高于对照麦田,平均增产率分别为7.2%、8.6%和7.4%。农田防护林的积极作用改善了
在室内进行了西花蓟马Frankliniella occidentalis(Pergande)种群对多杀菌素的抗性筛选和抗性遗传方式分析。经过2年多的汰选,抗性水平相比较初始种群提高了30倍,与同时测定的
本文研究了一年生的26个美洲黑杨及其杂种无性系在苗期对杨四瘿螨的忼性变异,并对美洲黑杨的抗螨机理进行了探讨。1、以叶片危害指数为表型抗性指标,以南京、泗洪等两地试验结
森林土壤是森林植被生长、发展的物质基础,既起着固定林木生长的作用,同时为林木生长提供所需营养。森林土壤肥力影响着林分的健康生长状态,肥力的衰退会引起森林植被生长及
In this paper, simple upper bounds are derived on the frame and bit error probabilities of binary linear codes over Additive white Gaussian noise(AWGN)channels.
本研究以景观生态学和地图学为研究理论基础,以西洞庭湖区森林资源分布图为主要数据源,运用地理信息系统软件ArcGIS为技术手段,勾绘西洞庭湖区森林景观类型图,建立西洞庭湖区
元数据对于促进林业信息的管理、共享和使用有着重要的意义,元数据理论在林业信息进一步挖掘中的应用对于林业信息研究发展有着极其深远的研究意义。通过元数据理论来描述林
提出了一种规则自校正模糊控制器,该控制器通过对模糊规则进行修改,使系统具有学习功能,从而改善控制器的性能,仿真结果表明该控制器具有很好的动态特性和鲁棒性 This paper pro
SERCOS为同步控制引进了全新的概念,它将同步控制技术提高到一个新的发展阶段.本文以高速无轴印刷机为应用实例,介绍SERCOS在高速无轴传动和交互通信方面的应用. SERCOS introduces a new co