荟萃分析:CT结肠镜检查

来源 :世界核心医学期刊文摘(胃肠病学分册) | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:shulin370
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Background: Computed tomographic (CT) colonography, also called virtual colono scopy, is an evolving technology under evaluation as a new method of screening f or colorectal cancer. However, its performance as a test has varied widely acros s studies, and the reasons for these discrepancies are poorly defined. Purpose: To systematically review the test performance of CT colonography compared to col onoscopy or surgery and to assess variables that may affect test performance. Da ta Sources: The PubMed, MEDLINE, and EMBASE databases and the Cochrane Controlle d Trials Register were searched for Englishlanguage articles published between January 1975 and February 2005. Study Selection: Prospective studies of adults undergoing CT colonography after full bowel preparation, with colonoscopy or sur gery as the gold standard, were selected. Studies had to have used stateofth eart technology, including at least a singledetector CT scanner with supine an d prone positioning, insufflation of the colon with air or carbon dioxide, colli mation smaller than 5 mm, and both 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional views durin g scan interpretation. The evaluators of the colonogram had to be unaware of the findings from use of the gold standard test. Data Abstraction: Data on sensitiv ity and specificity overall and for detection of polyps less than 6 mm, 6 to 9 m m, and greater than 9 mm in size were abstracted. Sensitivities and specificitie s weighted by sample size were calculated, and heterogeneity was explored by usi ng stratified analyses and metaregression. Data Synthesis: 33 studies provided data on 6393 patients. The sensitivity of CT colonography was heterogeneous but improved as polyp size increased (48%[95%CI, 25%to 70%] for detection of p olyps< 6 mm, 70%[CI, 55%to 84%] for polyps 6 to 9 mm, and 85%[CI, 79%to 91%] for polyps >9 mm). Characteristics of the CT colonography scanner, including width of collimation, type of detector, a nd mode of imaging, explained some of this heterogeneity. In contrast, specifici ty was homogenous (92%[CI, 89%to 96%] for detection of polyps < 6 mm, 93% [CI , 91%to 95%] for polyps 6 to 9 mm, and 97%[CI, 96%to 97%] for polyps >9 mm) . Limitations: The studies differed widely, and the extractable variables explai ned only a small amount of the heterogeneity. In addition, only a few studies ex amined the newest CT colonography technology. Conclusions: Computed tomographic colonography is highly specific, but the range of reported sensitivities is wide . Patient or scanner characteristics do not fully account for this variability, but collimation, type of scanner, and mode of imaging explain some of the discre pancy. This heterogeneity raises concerns about consistency of performance and a bout technical variability. These issues must be resolved before CT colonography can be advocated for generalized screening for colorectal cancer. Background: Computed tomographic (CT) colonography, also called virtual colono scopy, is an evolving technology under evaluation as a new method of screening f or colorectal cancer. However, its performance as a test has varied covered acrosses studies, and the reasons for These discrepancies are poorly defined. Purpose: To systematically review the test performance of CT colonography compared to col onoscopy or surgery and to assess assess that that may affect test performance. Da ta Sources: The PubMed, MEDLINE, and EMBASE databases and the Cochrane Controlled d Trials Register were searched for English-language articles published between January 1975 and February 2005. Study Selection: Prospective studies of adults under CT colonography after full bowel preparation, with colonoscopy or sur gery as the gold standard, were selected. Studies had to have used stateofth eart technology, including at least one single detector CT scanner with supine an d prone positioning, insuffla tion of the colon with air or carbon dioxide, colli mation smaller than 5 mm, and both both 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional views durin g scan interpretation. The evaluators of the colonogram had to be unaware of the findings from use of the gold standard test. Data Abstraction: Data on sensitivity and specificity overall and for detection of polyps less than 6 mm, 6 to 9 mm, and greater than 9 mm in size were abstracted. Sensitivities and specificitie s weighted by sample size were calculated, and heterogeneity The sensitivity of CT colonography was heterogeneous but improved as polyp size increased (48% [95% CI, 25% to 70%]) was explored by usi ng stratified analyzes and meta regressions. Data Synthesis: 33 studies provided data on 6393 patients for detection of p olyps <6 mm, 70% [CI, 55% to 84%] for polyps 6 to 9 mm, and 85% [CI, 79% to 91%] for polyps> 9 mm). Characteristics of the CT colonography scanner, including width of collimation, type of detector, a nd mode of imaging, so so me of this93% [CI, 91% to 95%] for polyps 6 to 9 mm, and 97% [CI, 96% to 97%] for polyps> 9 mm). Limitations: The studies differed widely, and the extractable variables explai ned only a small amount of the heterogeneity. In addition, only a few studies ex amined the newest CT colonography technology. Conclusions: Computed tomographic colonography is highly specific, but the range of reported sensitivities is wide. Patient or scanner characteristics do not fully account for this variability, but collimation, type of scanner, and mode of imaging explain some of the discrepancies. This heterogeneity raises concerns about consistency of performance and a bout technical variability. These issues must be resolved before CT colonography can be advocated for generalized screening for colorectal cancer.
其他文献
请下载后查看,本文暂不支持在线获取查看简介。 Please download to view, this article does not support online access to view profile.
期刊
不妨从一棵蔬菜的角度,检讨自己的傲慢。在电影《世上最快的印第安摩托》中,安东尼·霍普金斯扮演的老人说过一句台词:“不追求梦想的人生,就跟蔬菜一个样儿。”这部电影看过
烽火通信近日宣布,成功中标墨西哥电信光缆采购项目,这是在突破西班牙电信、意大利电信等跨国运营商之后所取得的又一国际市场成果。 FiberHome recently announced that it
上世纪70年代以来,世界各国轮式装甲车辆的发展始终非常活跃,许多车型已大规模装备部队,并在近代的局部战争中发挥了重要作用。在1999年的科索沃战争中.俄军乘坐BT开一80轮式
某视频网站办公室开了个赌局,赌土豆能否成功上市,赌资一顿饭。"我赌它上不了。"小V说,虽然他知道土豆上市应该没太大问题,但他还是决定赌它上不了,因为他并不希望土豆上市。如
邮政既服务经济发展,也服务文化建设;既是传承优秀文化传统的承载者,也是促进先进文化发展的参与者。当前,邮政正处于改革、发展和转型的关键时期,全面深入贯彻落实全会精神,
现代企业管理理论认为,企业发展具有明显的阶段性。邮电分营后,大多数邮政企业都会历经三个发展阶段:一是规模化阶段。在这一阶段,企业的各项业务收入快速增长,基础设施建设
在市场经济中私营与公有应不应平等竞争许一新在社会主义条件下,私营经济与公有制经济是否应平等竞争,能否平等竞争,怎样平等竞争,已成为人们议论纷纷的话题。平等竞争是建立社会
“市场经济与社会协调发展——《探索与争鸣》创刊10周年”学术座谈会近日先后在中国社会科学院、北京师范大学、中国人民大学,北京大学召开.北京各大专院校、科研单位、中央党校和国家机关的80多位专家学者参加了座谈,就“市场经济与社会协调发展”的主题展开了热烈的讨论。
社会主义市场中有企业法人和自然人双重主体。自然人既是消费者,又是生产要素劳动力的所有者,还是投资者,因此自然人构成了市场经济中的一个原生的经济主体。确立自然人的主