论文部分内容阅读
论文质量是实现科技工作者评价的重要指标。目前,论文质量的评价主要基于论文的被引频次和发表期刊共两种方式,而被引频次统计的滞后性和“以刊评文”的片面性,都影响了单篇论文质量评价中的科学性和准确性。文章以我国入选F5000论文的6019篇论文为样本,通过对专家评审意见进行知识图谱和共词分析,探索优秀论文评审的关键词特征,通过分析总结出优秀论文在创新、价值、内容及写作方面的特征,不仅为科技管理中识别优秀论文提供了方法支撑,也为论文质量评价和学者学术评价提供新的思路和参考。
The quality of the essay is an important index to realize the evaluation of science and technology workers. At present, the evaluation of the quality of the thesis is mainly based on the citation frequency of the essay and the total number of published journals. However, the lag of citation statistics and the one-sidedness of censoring articles all influence the quality evaluation of single essay Scientific and accurate. Based on the 6019 essays selected by F5000 in China, the article explores the key words characteristics of excellent essay reviews by analyzing the expert opinions and the common words, and summarizes the innovation, value, content and writing of excellent essays Not only provides the method support for identifying outstanding papers in the management of science and technology, but also provides new ideas and references for the quality evaluation of the thesis and academic evaluation of scholars.