去年,笔者在《语文教学通讯》上读到毛荣富老师对一些青年教师说的一句话“不要把语文课上得太像语文课”,觉得它闪烁着语文教学思辨之光,颇值得寻味。的确,“太像语文课”就把课限定死了,没了个性也就失了灵气。语文教学要讲究“活”,要让学生提得起兴趣;语文教学要讲究“实”,要让学生真正有所得。只活不实,易流于表面花哨;只实不活,又会显得呆板枯燥。相隔三年,给两届学生用不同的方法上同一篇课文《鸿门宴》,愈发觉得活和实的有机结合是上好语文课的关键。(清水河县职业中学,内 Last year, the author read “The Language Teaching Newsletter” that Mao Rongfu’s teacher said something to some young teachers: “Don’t put language classes too much like Chinese language classes.” I feel that it flashes the light of speculative thinking in Chinese language teaching and it is worth exploring. Indeed, “too much like a language lesson” puts the class to death, and without personality it loses its aura. Language teaching should pay attention to “living” and students should be able to pay attention to it; language teaching should pay attention to “reality” and allow students to truly gain. Only live is not true, easy to flow on the surface fancy; only really not live, it will look dull. Three years later, two students were given different methods in the same text, “The Banquet of Banquet”, and it became increasingly clear that the organic combination of living and realism was the key to a good language lesson. (Qingshuihe County Vocational Middle School, within