Can patients determine the level of their dysphagia?

来源 :World Journal of Gastroenterology | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:roc59516663
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM To determine if patients can localise dysphagia level determined endoscopically or radiologically and association of gender, age, level and pathology.METHODS Retrospective review of consecutive patients presenting to dysphagia hotline between March 2004 and March 2015 was carried out. Demographics, clinical history and investigation findings were recorded including patient perception of obstruction level (pharyngeal, mid sternal or low sternal) was documented and the actual level of obstruction found on endoscopic or radiological examination (if any) was noted. All patients with evidence of obstruction including oesophagealcarcinoma, peptic stricture, Schatzki ring, oesophageal pouch and cricopharyngeal hypertrophy were included in the study who had given a perceived level of dysphagia. The upper GI endoscopy reports (barium study where upper GI endoscopy was not performed) were reviewed to confirm the distance of obstructing lesion from central incisors. A previously described anatomical classification of oesophagus was used to define the level of obstruction to be upper, middle or lower oesophagus and this was compared with patient perceived level.RESULTS Three thousand six hundred and sixty-eight patients were included, 42.0% of who were female, mean age 70.7 ± 12.8 years old. Of those with obstructing lesions, 726 gave a perceived level of dysphagia: 37.2% had oesophageal cancer, 36.0% peptic stricture, 13.1% pharyngeal pouches, 10.3% Schatzki rings and 3.3% achalasia. Twenty-seven point five percent of patients reported pharyngeal level (upper) dysphagia, 36.9% mid sternal dysphagia and 25.9% lower sternal dysphagia (9.5% reported multiple levels). The level of obstructing lesion seen on diagnostic testing was upper (17.2%), mid (19.4%) or lower (62.9%) or combined (0.3%). When patients localised their level of dysphagia to a single level, the kappa statistic was 0.245 (P < 0.001), indicating fair agreement. 48% of patients reporting a single level of dysphagia were accurate in localising the obstructing pathology. With respect to pathology, patients with pharyngeal pouches were most accurate localising their level of dysphagia(P < 0.001). With respect to level of dysphagia, those with pharyngeal level lesions were best able to identify the level of dysphagia accurately (P < 0.001). No association (P > 0.05) was found between gender, patient age or clinical symptoms with their ability to detect the level of dysphagia.CONCLUSION Patient perceived level of dysphagia is unreliable in determining actual level of obstructing pathology and should not be used to tailor investigations. AIM To determine if patients can localise dysphagia level determined endoscopically or radiologically and association of gender, age, level and pathology. METHODS Retrospective review of consecutive patients presenting to dysphagia hotline between March 2004 and March 2015 was carried out. Demographics, clinical history and investigation findings were recorded including patient perception of obstruction level (pharyngeal, mid sternal or low sternal) was documented and the actual level of obstruction found on endoscopic or radiological examination (if any) was noted. All patients with evidence of obstruction including oesophagealcarcinoma, peptic stricture , Schatzki ring, oesophageal pouch and cricopharyngeal hypertrophy were included in the study who had given a perceived level of dysphagia. The upper GI endoscopy reports (barium study where upper GI endoscopy was not performed) were reviewed to confirm the distance of obstructing lesion from central incisors. A previously described ana tomical classification of oesophagus was used to define the level of obstruction to be upper, middle or lower oesophagus and this was compared with patient perceived level .RESULTS Three thousand six hundred and sixty-eight patients were included, 42.0% of who were female, mean age 70.7 ± 12.8 years old. Of those with obstructing lesions, 726 gave a perceived level of dysphagia: 37.2% had oesophageal cancer, 36.0% peptic stricture, 13.1% pharyngeal pouches, 10.3% Schatzki rings and 3.3% achalasia. Twenty-seven point The percent of patients reported pharyngeal level (upper) dysphagia, 36.9% mid sternal dysphagia and 25.9% lower sternal dysphagia (9.5% reported multiple levels). The level of obstructing lesion seen on diagnostic testing was upper (17.2%), mid When patients localised their level of dysphagia to a single level, the kappa statistic was 0.245 (P <0.001), indicating fair agreement. 48% of patients reporting a single level (%) or lower (62.9% of dysp hWith respect to pathology, patients with pharyngeal pouches were most accurate localising their level of dysphagia (P <0.001). With respect to level of dysphagia, those with pharyngeal level lesions were best able to identify the level of dysphagia accurately (P <0.001). No association (P> 0.05) was found between gender, patient age or clinical symptoms with their ability to detect the level of dysphagia. CONCLUSION Patient perceived level of dysphagia is unreliable in determining actual level of obstructing pathology and should not be used to tailor investigations.
其他文献
该实验应用电生理学、组织病理学、免疫组织化学、TUNEL法和荧光定量RT-PCR等方法,建立新型的全脑缺血再灌注模型,检测脑缺血再灌注后神经元凋亡、bcl-2蛋白和CPP32mRNA的表
以22613综采工作面为工程背景,针对该工作面地质构造较多,断层、无炭柱较多,采区上部覆盖煤柱较多三大特点,详细论述在工作面初采期间强制放顶作业过程中,深孔爆破技术的作业
本文通过分析公路施工企业腐败问题的成因及特点,提出如何做好公路施工企业党风廉政建设的对策建议。 Based on the analysis of the causes and characteristics of highwa
变频控制技术具有智能化的特点,可以满足煤矿行业日益增长的开采需求.在煤矿机电设备作业过程中采用该技术,可以安全快捷地进行开采,逐渐成为行业的主流.本文就变频控制技术
东海大部分开发的气藏为水驱气藏,生产该类气藏的气井部分已出水,见水后产量递减快,严重影响气藏正常生产.对不带气举阀的井提出一种油管打孔隔离气举工艺,实现“管内气举阀
用刷手机的方式来完成支付不但有趣而且怏捷安全。但是由于企业间的争斗和它们的贪婪,这一天将会延后至更遥远的未来真的到了信用卡让位的时候了吗?谷歌在2011年推出谷歌钱包
针对某区块油田废液处理固相含量较高、沉降时间长等技术难题,研发磁絮凝工艺.通过室内试验,当磁粉平均粒径45μm时,磁粉投加量为14 g/L时,可将传统沉降时间缩短80%,絮体更加
对某采油厂联合站隐患治理工程存在的危险、有害因素进行全面分析的基础上,运用检查表法、预先危险性分析法对该项目进行分析评价,并提出了减少危险发生的相应对策措施.
3月16日,广东省教育纪检监察工作会议在广州召开。省纪委副书记丘海出席会议并讲话。省委教育工委书记、省教育厅党组书记、省教育厅厅长罗伟其到会讲话。省教育纪工委书记、
目的:检测再生障碍性贫血(简称再障)患者几种造血相关免疫分子的表达,探讨其与再障发病的关系.方法:对20例再障患者及8例正常对照1.用酶联免疫法检测骨髓和外周血中G-CSF、TN