黄振南先生的《中法战争诸役考》在对诸多史料进行充分研究的基础上 ,对中法战争中似乎已成定论的“基隆大捷”提出大胆质疑 ,对法军在淡水的伤亡人数进行认真考证 ,并对刘铭传从基隆撤军的功过是非作了重新评价。这些观点证据确凿、见解独到 ,是刘铭传抗法斗争研究的新突破 On the basis of ample research on many historical materials, Mr. Huang Zhennan’s “Sino-French War Campaign Tests” boldly questioned the “Clone of Keelung,” a seemingly settled issue in the Sino-French War, and took seriously the number of French troops killed and wounded in Danshui Textual criticism and reassessment of the merits and demerits of Liu Ming Chuan’s withdrawal from Keelung. The evidence of these opinions is conclusive and the opinions are unique. This is a new breakthrough in the study of the anti-law struggle by Liu Mingchuan