朱法贞先生的《恩格斯两种生产理论再探讨》(《探索》89年第1期;以下简称《再探讨》)对我的《恩格斯两种生产理论探讨》(《社会科学研究》87年第3期)一文提出了商榷,并同意以我提出的“严格地以恩格斯的有关论述为立论的出发点”,参与讨论;但通观《再探讨》全文,我认为朱先生没有按照这一要求参与讨论,因而他的商榷是缺乏根据的。 Zhu Fazhen’s “Engels two kinds of production theory and then explore” (“Exploration” 89, No. 1; hereinafter referred to as “re-discussion) on my” Engels two kinds of production theory “(” Social Science Research “87 years 3 Period), and agreed to participate in the discussion on the basis of ”the starting point of strictly speaking Engels’ related argument“ put forward by me; but in view of the full text of ”re-discussion," I think that Mr. Zhu did not participate in the discussion in accordance with this requirement, Therefore, his argument is unfounded.