【裁判要旨】以卸货作业方式实施的海难救助,是常见的海难救助方法之一。判断是否海难救助,要看是否符合海难救助的构成要件,而不取决于实施救助的方式。救助人在其作业区内以卸货作业方式实施的海难救助,在确定救助报酬时,应扣除救助人正常装卸作业的费用。□案号一审:(2011)甬海法事初字第63号二审:(2013)浙海终字第41号 [Referee motto] The unloading operation to implement the salvage aid, is one of the common methods of salvage aid. Determine whether the salvage, whether to meet the composition of the salvage elements, and does not depend on the implementation of the rescue. Salvors in its area of ​​operations to unload operations carried out by the salvage, in determining the salvage remuneration, salvage workers should be deducted from the normal loading and unloading costs. □ Case No. First instance: (2011) Yonghai Fa Shi Chu Zi No. 63 Second instance: (2013) Zhe Hai Zhong Zi No. 41