虞云国、陶敏两位先生校勘《南部新书》后认为《四库全书》本颇具校勘价值。我们通过对《南部新书》异文详细比较,认为《四库全书》本的校勘虽有可取,但轻率甚至谬误的校勘不少。伍崇曜本与四库本同源,又未经馆臣校改,价值相对更高。 Yu Yunguo, Tao Min two gentlemen collate the “Southern New Book” that “Sikuquanshu” quite a collated value. Through a detailed comparison of the foreign languages ​​of the “Southern New Book,” we think that the collation of this book of Sikuquanshu is preferable, but there are quite a lot of simplistic and even fallacious collations. Wu Chong Yao with the four libraries of the same origin, but also without the college reform, the value is relatively higher.