读了张炎烈同志的《图书馆学的困扰与方向》(载《图书情报工作》1990年第1期),作者对图书馆学发展的急切心情固然可以理解,但文中的一些观点实难苟同,现与作者商榷。一、图书馆学真的发生了危机吗? 文章一开始就提出“图书馆学的困境”。作者是这样描述的:“翻开图书馆学杂志,几乎到处都可以看到对图书馆学的科学性及图书馆社会地位不满的感叹。在科学史上,其它学科,诸如数学、物理、化学等等,都出现过“危机”。不 Reading Comrade Zhang Yanlie’s “Problems and Direction of Library Science” (contained in “Library and Information Service” No. 1, 1990), the author’s anxiety about the development of library science is certainly understandable. However, some of the views in this paper are hard to come by. Now with the author to discuss. First, the library science really had a crisis? The article put forward the “plight of library science.” The author describes it this way: “In the library science magazine, you can see the exclamation about the science of library science and the social status of libraries almost everywhere. In the history of science, other disciplines such as mathematics, physics, chemistry, etc. There have been ”crisis." No