Reviews in Garnet-Biotite Geothermometer: Its Versions, Inherent Problems of Accuracy and Precis

来源 :Chinese Journal of Geochemistry | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:liuln6
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
This paper briefly introduces twenty one versions of garnet biotite Fe Mg exchange geothermometry, points out the sources of systematic errors inherent in geothermometry. The sources lie in that: (1) ideal Fe Mg mixing in garnet and biotite is assumed; (2) non ideal properties of both garnet and biotite are not considered completely; (3) minor elements—Mn, Ca in garnet, and Al Ⅵ, Ti, Mn in biotite are almost neglected; (4) effects of pressure on equilibrium, although little, are almost not taken into consideration, and experiments were conducted at one fixed pressure; (5) the data used for regression analysis is too scarce in quantity; (6) internal consistency of the data used for empirical calibration is not fully guaranteed; (7) the authors take energy parameters W’s (Margule’s parameters) independent of pressure and temperature, though the former are actually the functions of the latter items; and (8) the most important composition activity relationship is not consistent with the mineral compositions used for calibration. Furthermore, it is believed that empirical calibrations cannot avoid the following problems: (1) effect of retrograde metamorphism; (2) inconsistent data set; (3) effect of pressure on temperature estimation; and (4) effect of Fe 3+ calculation. Exact experimental work should be done in order to accurately calibrate the geothermometer in which the Margule’s parameters should be treated as the functions of pressure, temperature, and mineral compositions. This paper briefly introduces twenty one versions of garnet biotite Fe Mg exchange geothermometry, points out the sources of systematic errors inherent in geothermometry. The sources lie in that: (1) ideal Fe Mg mixing in garnet and biotite is assumed; (2) non ideal properties of both garnet and biotite are not considered completely; (3) minor elements-Mn, Ca in garnet, and Al VI, Ti, Mn in biotite are almost neglected; (4) effects of pressure on equilibrium, although little, are (5) the data used for regression analysis is too scarce in quantity; (6) internal consistency of the data used for empirical calibration is not fully guaranteed; (7) the authors take energy parameters W’s (Margule’s parameters) independent of pressure and temperature, though the former are actually the functions of the latter items; and (8) the most important composition activity activity is not consistent with the mineral compositions used for calibration. (1) effect of retrograde metamorphism; (2) inconsistent data set; (3) effect of pressure on temperature estimation; and (4 ) effect of Fe 3+ calculation. Exact experimental work should be done in order to accurately calibrate the geothermometer in which the Margule’s parameters should be treated as the functions of pressure, temperature, and mineral compositions.
其他文献
为了获取原始油层数据,莫比尔北海石油公司在一口水平开发并中进行了随射孔生产测井。该井位于莫比尔公司经营的北海内维斯油田。斯伦贝谢油田服务集团提供测井和射孔服务。测
In order to reduce transmission loss of the optical waveguide in Mach-Zehnder (M-Z) electro-optical (EO) polymer modulator,the basic iterative formula of semi-v
城市群发展与府际协作,是近几年我国城镇化战略与政府治理能力实践与理论中不断被提及的概念。过去,我们对城市群的理解与经济区域相类似,强调它在产业聚集上的功能,具有地理相邻、交通便利等特点。但是,当前我国城市群已经成为地方公共事务管理的延伸,超出了原有区域经济的框架。在此背景下,
将自组织临界现象理论在地震预报领域作深入的应用研究,根据各量的物理含义重新讨论了在地震科学中的应用,并用重整化群方法对强震前中小地震增强现象的临界点问题进行研究,
长期以来,人们一直认为中国大陆所在的亚欧板块受到东部太平洋板块向西的俯冲,经过长达三年多的观测研究,我国科学家对这种观点首次提出质疑。中国科学院上海天文台研究员朱文耀
本报告讨论北海中部Fulmar油田时延地震数据的分析结果。这项研究旨在评价时延地震技术在用传统数据进行油藏内流体运移和压力变化监测方面的潜力。选择Fulmar油田作为时延
陕西柞水东甘沟金矿是一个构造角砾岩型氧化金矿床,氧化带深约200 m ,地表延长达4 000 m 。前人对其进行过少量普查和开发( 全泥氰化)工作。笔者在充分调查研究的基础上,提出了一个科学、合
广东省启动建设的生态景观林带,是指全省主要高速公路、铁路和“四江”两侧各1公里可视范围内山地,沿海岸线的沙地和滩涂的生态景观带;高速公路、铁路主干道两侧各20~50米的绿
目的探究急性心肌梗死不典型心电图特点的分析及意义。方法选取我院急性心肌梗死患者25例,收治时间在2012年3月至2014年5月期间,对患者不典型心电图特点进行分析。结果 25例
尽管地壳最上部的构造、岩性和地球化学条件控制着内生金属矿床的就位,然而最大量金属富集的地点和空间分布却常被幔根构造间断面(mantlerootedstructuraldiscontinuity)所控制。这些构造间断面延长几百到几千km,这表