论文部分内容阅读
秦犁先生《别拿悬钩当悬坠》一文,是针对张铨先生《浅议“台钓”、“悬坠钩”和“竞技钓”》一文的不同意见。我对秦文中的有的说法,有些不同意见,写在下面,不知对不对,请秦先生指正。一、悬坠钓法只能是“坠悬而钩不悬吗”? 秦先生在文中提出了一个新词:‘传统悬钩钓法(但我观张铨先生文中没有这个新词,不知秦先生何以据此而驳的?),对照“现代悬坠钓”作不同比较。秦先生说:“悬坠钓组的特点是坠悬而钩不悬。”真是这样吗?我认为,秦先生在这里只是说到“现代悬坠钓法”的基本调漂法和基本钓法(钓底),而不是全部,因而把“坠悬而钩不悬”概括为悬坠钓组的“特点”,就不那么确切了。众所周知,悬坠钓法发展到秦先生论的“现代悬坠钓法”阶段,已是今非昔比了,它有“离底钓”、“半水钓”、“一漂深钓”法等等。这些,都归“悬坠钓组”和“悬坠钓法”的范围,都是“现代悬坠钓法”,而且它们的钩都无例外地在水体中“悬”,并没有固守“钩饵触底”老一套;秦先生恐怕不会把这些归纳为“传统悬钩钓法”吧? 二、所谓“传统悬钩钓法”的“坠悬而钩跟
Mr. Qin Li’s article “Do not Take the Suspension as a Pendant” is a dissenting opinion on Mr. Zhang Quan’s discussion of “Taiwan fishing”, “hanging hook” and “competitive fishing”. I have some sayings in Qin Wen, some different opinions, written below, I do not know right or wrong, please correct me Qin. First, the hanging fishing method can only be “hanging and hook does not hang it?” Mr. Qin put forward a new word in the text: ’Traditional hook fishing (but I see Mr. Zhang Quan article does not have this new word, I do not know Qin Why should this be refuted?), Compare “modern hanging fishing” for different comparisons. Mr. Qin said: “The characteristics of the hanging fishing group is hanging and hanging hook.” Really? I think, here, Mr. Qin just said “ (Fishing the bottom), but not all, it is not so precise to generalize the ”pendant“ as the ”peculiarity“ of a suspended fishing tackle. As we all know, the development of hanging fishing method developed to Mr. Qin’s ”modern hanging fishing method“ stage, it is not the past, and it has the ”bottom fishing“, ”half fishing“, ”one drift fishing“ method and many more. These are all in the range of ”hanging fishing group“ and ”hanging fishing method“, are ”modern hanging fishing method“, and their hooks are without exception in the water ”hanging“ and did not stick to the ”hook Bait touch the bottom, “the old one; I’m afraid I’m afraid Qin will not be summarized as” the traditional hook fishing method “? Second, the so-called” traditional hook hook fishing method "