我完全赞同魏鑫同志《学生军训不能取代民兵训练》的文章(见《军事知识》1987年第1期),但党言犹未尽,故再补充几句。学生军训的性质不同于民兵。大中学生都是涉世未深的青少年,他们在学生这个位置上的存在毕竟是暂时的,过渡性的。他们中的多数尚未成年,或虽已成年而思想并不完全成熟。因而,学生训练还属于军事启蒙教育,或谓之役前基础训练,即了解军事基础 I fully agree with Comrade Wei Xin’s article “Military training can not replace militia training” (see “Military Knowledge”, No. 1, 1987), but the party’s speech is still unfinished. Therefore, I will add a few more. The nature of student military training is different from that of militia. Students from both middle and high school are inexperienced young people who, after all, are temporary and transitional in their position as students. Most of them have not yet reached adulthood, or their thoughts are not fully mature despite their adulthood. Thus, student training also belongs to military enlightenment education, or pre-service basic training, that is, understand the military basis