法人名誉权与商誉权皆有实证法上的基础,两种保护模式间却存在体系冲突,文章先运用体系解释、历史解释、目的解释、比较法解释等方法,形成了商誉保护的解释论。在立法论上考虑,法人名誉权概念欠缺合理性,与人格权制度的立法目的不合,更与法人人格的本质难以协调。法人名誉权是“双重继受”食洋不化之结果,未来的民法典应予以抛弃。 The legal rights of reputation and goodwill both have the foundation of the positive law. There is a system conflict between the two protection modes. The article first uses the methods of system explanation, history explanation, purpose explanation and comparative law interpretation to form the explanation of goodwill protection s. Considered in the legislative argument, the lack of rationality of the concept of corporate reputation, which is incompatible with the legislative purpose of the personality right system, is even more difficult to reconcile with the nature of corporate personality. The legal person’s reputation is the result of “double inheritance” and the future civil code should be abandoned.