论文部分内容阅读
中国有句古话,叫做“有理走遍天下,无理寸步难行”。然而,一机电设备总公司最近在一场购销纠纷中自认有“理”却当了被告,愤而当庭反诉,再上诉,也均告败诉,这使他们深深自责:我们有理为什么就打不赢官司?1997年4月,某乡人民政府与机电设备总公司第四分公司经日头协商,向其购买天津雁牌标准双排1043B型汽车一辆。当月28日,某乡人民政府交给第四分公司定金5000元,第四分公司出具收条一张,注明车价为32200元,已付定金5000元,5月6日左右通知用户提车。并附用户电话号码和联系人,加盖了第四分公司发票专用章。然而,到6月10日,该乡人民政府却一纸诉状将机电设备总公司(因第四分公司不具法人资格)送上了中原区人民法院的被告席。诉状中称因被告违约,使我方至今未提货,请求判令被告双倍返还定金10000元。坐上被告席的机电设备总公司大呼冤枉,并当庭反诉,述称“我们按双方约定,及
There is an old saying in China, called ”rational management of the world, unreasonable“. However, an electromechanical equipment head office in a dispute recently in the purchase and sale of self-righteousness, but when the defendant, indignant court counterclaims, appeals, but also loses the complaint, which makes them deeply remorse: we In April 1997, the people’s government of a certain township and the fourth branch of the Electromechanical Equipment Corporation, after consultation with the Japanese side, purchased a standard double-row type 1043B vehicle from Tianjin Yangei. On the 28th of the same month, a people’s government of a township handed over a deposit of 5,000 yuan to the fourth branch office and a fourth branch issued a receipt, stating that the price of the car was 32,200 yuan and the deposit paid 5,000 yuan, notifying the user about May 6 car. Attached to the user’s phone number and contact, affixed with the fourth branch invoice seal. However, by June 10, the township government issued a paper complaint to the mechanical and electrical equipment head office (because the fourth branch does not have the legal personality) sent to the Zhongyuan District People’s Court dock. The petition said the defendant for breach of contract, so that we have not yet delivery, request the defendant double return deposit of 10,000 yuan. Sitting on the dock of the Electromechanical Equipment Corporation shouted innocent, and counterclaimed in court, said ”We are as agreed by both parties, and