论文部分内容阅读
我国首例由非法代孕引发的监护权纠纷案中,代孕行为的无效不应闯入亲属法的权利领域。无效的民事行为产生的法律后果不一定无效,本案涉及的代孕行为无效,但造成的法律后果是两个孩子的出生,在伦理上,不论孩子是婚生还是非婚生子女,都应当等同于婚生子女进行对待。在法律上,可类推适用继子女的法律关系进行认定。最重要的是,必须从儿童利益最大化角度出发,做出最有利于孩子成长的判决。
In China’s first case of custody arising from illegal surrogacy, the invalidation of surrogacy should not break into the area of rights of relative law. The legal consequences of an invalid civil act are not necessarily null and void and the surrogacy involved in this case is invalid but the legal consequence is the birth of two children. Ethically, a child should be equal to a married child regardless of whether they are born or unmarried Children are treated. Legally, the legal relationship of step-children can be applied analogy. Most importantly, judgments that are most beneficial to children’s growth must be made in the light of the interests of children.