聚众斗殴罪是一个讨论已久的罪名,但是依然有很多尚未解决或解决不当的问题。很多新颖的观点,本质上并没有坚实的法理基础。应当认为,一般参加者是主体认定的关键;斗殴不可拆分;成立本罪必须双方都满3人;流氓动机具有存在的必要性;“社会影响恶劣”和“造成社会严重混乱”的认定标准需要厘清;使用目的作为认定“械”的标准是较为妥当的;“多次”是累犯制度的一部分。 The crime of gathering people for a fight is a long-debated charge, but there are still many unresolved or solved problems. Many new ideas, in essence, do not have a solid legal basis. It should be considered that the general participants are the key to the determination of the main body; the fight can not be split; the three parties must be both full upon the founding of the crime; the motive of rogue has the necessity of existence; the “bad social influence” and the “serious social disorder” “The identification criteria need to be clarified; the use of the purpose as a standard” “is more appropriate; ” many times "is a part of the recidivism system.