论最密切联系原则在中国的适用:比较法视角

被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:dfgforrest
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
The Title of this dissertation is "The Application of’Most Significant Relationship’in the Chinese Judicial System:A Comparative Law Perspective".In recent years, the doctrine of most significant relationship has received more attention. This doctrine emerged with the eruption of the "conflict revolution", which brought new approaches and methodology to the area of private international law or conflict of laws. Europe and other countries, including China, also adopted it or similar theories in their legislations and judicial system, after the United States had adopted this doctrine or most significant relationship. However, the role of this doctrine remains vague and ambiguous in the Chinese judicial system, and its application presents considerable shortcomings and problems. Thus, I will complete a comparative analysis of the application of most significant relationship, with references to its application in other jurisdictions, such as the United States, Europe, and other countries.In this dissertation, I suggest that the Chinese application of most significant relationship will resemble the style adopted in Europe. It is very difficult for China to completely follow the model of the United States, as both China and the United States belong to different legal families. However, Chinese law can still incorporate some advantages from American conflict of laws theories and practice. The application of the most significant relationship in Chinese law has problems because of the absence of judicial reasoning, the lack of explicit and widely accepted principles and approaches, the lack of legal knowledge and experience in making judicial decisions in a flexible way according to general principle, as well as the lack of references and precedents. Therefore, in this dissertation, I also suggest different measures China can take in responding to these problems with the cooperation of the judicial departments, legislature, and scholars.In this dissertation, I also refer to several judicial and arbitration cases in order to illustrate how the doctrine of the most significant relationship can be applied in China. Through the analysis of specific cases, I analyze the shortcomings of judgments and the methodology underlying those judgments.This dissertation is divided into four chapters. The first chapter consists of the introduction of this dissertation, the structure of whole dissertation, and a brief overview of the historical development of conflict of laws theories. The second chapter introduces the emergence of the most significant relationship, the application of this doctrine in the United States, Europe and other countries, and in China. This dissertation also makes a comparison between styles of application of this doctrine within those jurisdictions. The third chapter presents cases judged by courts or arbitration committees and provides analyses for of the cases. The fourth chapter summarizes the observations of three preceding chapters and offers final conclusions of this dissertation, including suggesting some measures to tackle those problems encountered in the application of the doctrine.
其他文献
<正>一、引言城镇化是内蒙古经济社会发展进程中一个重要的历史阶段,自内蒙古提出工业化、城镇化与农牧业产业化的发展战略以来,内蒙古经济社会高速发展,城镇化率逐年上升。
当前,全球环境问题凸显,温室效应、厄尔尼诺现象等已经成为人们必须面对并想办法解决的问题,而减少二氧化碳的排放量可以在一定程度上缓解这个问题。在这一过程中,碳汇造林是
自上世纪八十年代以来,伴随我国经济的飞速发展,我国社会的城市化和汽车化发展也十分迅猛,由此也带来了道路拥挤、交通堵塞和交通事故等社会问题,造成城市的幸福指数下降、社
对《教育研究》在2000-2010年间刊载论文的主题变迁态势进行统计分析,可以看出,随着农村教育在经济和社会发展中的作用日愈提高,农村教育研究主题发生了不同程度的变迁,这主
农村基础教育培养目标的"内卷化"样态表现为"离农"和"为农"的交锋对峙。在基础教育目标定位过程中,曲解了其内在的神圣内涵,不仅缺乏动态的整体把握全局观,而且形成了城乡二
<正>近两年来,受互联网搅局的房地产中介服务业风云剧变。其中,以线下门店为载体,以经纪人为基础的传统中介谋求变革,自身转型或与有线上入口资源的经纪公司合作;而在过去专
雷达信号脉内调制特征识别技术是电子情报侦察系统进行目标信号识别的重要手段,它是指电子侦测系统在时域、频域和空域已截获雷达信号的基础上,对这些信号进行脉内调制特征识
不久前,FDA批准了由Amgen生产的既能治疗慢性肾病透析病人的继发性甲状旁腺功能亢进,也能治疗副甲状腺癌病人血钙过多的新药Sensipar(cinacalcet,西那卡塞).
马克思主义政治经济学指出,没有生产,就没有消费,但是,没有消费,也就没有生产,因为如果这样,生产就没有目的。消费在社会生产和生活中占有举足轻重的地位。但是,在资本主义工
<正>忘掉橱窗陈列和平面广告吧,这些手段已经过时了,如今是网络广告的天下。品牌赞助、征文大赛、抽奖活动、广告植入以及在线互动等几乎已成市场推广常态,可谓创意无限、无