对仲裁制度中仲裁的独立性和民事诉讼制度中审判的独立性进行比较分析 ,民事审判制度改革可以从仲裁制度中进行借鉴 ,可从保证法院的外部独立、审判庭的独立和法官身份的独立三个层次入手进行改革 ,以促进审判独立的实现 The comparative analysis of the independence of arbitration in the arbitration system and the independence of the trial in the civil procedure system, the reform of the civil judicial system can learn from the arbitration system, from the assurance of the external independence of the court, the independence of the court and the independence of the judge Three levels to start the reform, to promote the independence of the trial