“现代化的可选择性”命题是当代哲学社会科学领域的重大命题。安德鲁·芬柏格从技术的可选择性出发对该命题进行了言之成理的论证。本文首先扼要介绍了芬柏格关于该命题论证的依据和思路,然后给出自己的分析、批评和关于该命题论证应有思路框架的建议,以期引发我国学者对该命题展开更深入的探讨。 命 The “alternative of modernization” proposition is a major proposition in the field of contemporary philosophy and social sciences. Andrew Finkberger justified the proposition from a technical standpoint. In the first place, I briefly introduce the foundation and ideas of Feenberg’s argumentation on this proposition, and then give my own analysis, criticism and suggestion on the ideological framework that this proposition should argue, with a view to triggering a more in-depth discussion on this proposition by our scholars.