论文部分内容阅读
王亚新先生的《法官独立的政治含义》是一篇从制度主义视角审视中国司法制度的力作,对中国法院做出极具洞察力的制度分析。本着吹毛求疵的精神,本文通过重新解构这一博弈均衡的方式,考察王亚新先生在论证这种“脆弱的动态平衡”的过程中所缺失的视角,以及这些缺失对“均衡论”可能产生的影响,并以此为据,展望四中全会以来依法治国、依宪执政的改革。文中所谓脆弱的动态平衡,实际上是指自利的行为者,特别是法院与法官,在“司法行政化”与“司法地
Mr. Wang Yaxin’s ”Political Meaning of Judges’ Independence“ is a masterpiece that examines China’s judicial system from a institutionalism perspective and makes a very insightful institutional analysis of Chinese courts. In the spirit of picking fault, this dissertation attempts to reconstruct the equilibrium of this game by examining the missing perspectives of Mr. Wang Yaxin in demonstrating such a fragile dynamic equilibrium, The possible impact and based on this, we can look forward to the reform of governing the country according to law and governing the country according to law since the Fourth Plenary Session of the Fourth Plenary Session. The so-called fragile dynamic balance in this article actually refers to the self-interested actors, especially the courts and the judges. In the ”judicial administration“ and ”judicial"