论文部分内容阅读
2010年11月上半月,本刊以《一份欠款证明的真伪之争》为题,报道了山东省桓台社会福利橡胶助剂厂(下称助剂厂)和原博山天通物资运销处负责人张元兵之间的煤炭欠款纠纷。2001年12月6日,张元兵将助剂厂告上法庭,要求支付所欠煤款56.7万余元。法院一审判决驳回其起诉。张元兵上诉后,被二审驳回上诉,维持原判。张元兵申诉至山东省高院。2010年1月25日,山东省高院作出民事判决,支持了张元兵的诉求助剂厂对此不服,申诉至最高法院。2010年7月7日,最高法院决定立案审查。2011年2月28日,最高法院作出民事裁定,提审这起买卖合同纠纷案。
In the first half of November 2010, the journal titled “Conflicts between Authenticity and Probability of Evidence of Debt Proof”, reported that Huantai Shandong Social Welfare Rubber Auxiliary Plant (hereafter auxiliaries) and former Boshan Tian Tong Dispute of coal arrears between Zhang Yuanbing, head of materials distribution and sales department. December 6, 2001, Zhang Yuanbing will auxiliaries to court, asking for payment of owed 56.7 million yuan of coal. The court of first instance dismissed the prosecution. After Zhang Yuanbing appealed, he was dismissed for appeal by the second instance and upheld the original verdict. Zhang Yuanbing petition to Shandong Provincial High Court. January 25, 2010, Shandong Provincial High Court made a civil verdict in support of Zhang Yuanbing appeals additives plant this dissatisfaction, petition to the Supreme Court. July 7, 2010, the Supreme Court decided to file a case review. February 28, 2011, the Supreme Court made a civil ruling, to consider the sale of this contract dispute case.