College Admissions Contrasts China and the U.S.

来源 :China Pictorial | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:bianhaoyi1000
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  Three days in one early July, 34 years ago, remain deeply rooted in my memory as some of the most memorable moments of my life. I knew that the gaokao was a three-day test that would have more impact on the future trajectory of my life than anything else I could imagine. Two decades later, I watched my son, born and raised in the United States, graduate from a private high school in New Jersey. Comparing my son’s college application process with my own, I was continually awed by the differences, even after helping many high-school seniors apply for college.
  The key character of gaokao is “kao,”meaning “test.” The sole college admission determiner in China and some other Asian countries such as South Korea and Japan is the overall score on the final test from high school. In China’s gaokao, you could miss your dream school by one point on the 750-point scale. One incorrect answer could easily place you behind several thousand students in your gaokao judiciary district, typically the province or the city in which the student resides. To maximize fairness, the Chinese college admission system focuses on a single or a small set of quantitatively measurable parameters to evaluate talent based on a set of national exams which typically last a couple of days.
  Some Chinese people call the SAT(Scholastic Assessment Test) the “American gaokao.” To be fair, this is a far-off comparison. Although SAT scores are an important component of a student’s college application profile, they have a far less crucial role. The academic evaluation is only one part of holistic evaluation criteria considered by the U.S. college admission system. And the SAT score is only one number of many on a student’s academic evaluation. The academic evaluation also includes a student’s complete high-school transcript and scores on other standardized tests such as AP (Advanced Placement) exams. Another key difference is that a student can take the SAT or other standardized tests multiple times, which significantly reduces the pressure on the test taker.
  The college admission processes in China and the United States represent opposite sides of the spectrum. Countries like Canada and Britain are somewhere in between. With an aim toward maximum equality, China’s evaluation is based solely on final academic tests. In contrast, the U.S. college admission system evaluates applicants based on a comprehensive approach considering not only test scores but also various other factors such as high-school curriculum and transcript, teacher recommendations, community service, leadership, extracurricular activities, and personal interests.   A few fundamental reasons inspired the United States to adopt this evaluation method. Recognizing that a successful society is based on diverse talents and that students may have wide-ranging talents which are impossible to judge with a single test, the institutions argue that society needs leaders and workers who can maximize contributions to the advancement of society across all fields. Administrators recognize that potential contributions may not correlate with test scores. To achieve greater fairness, the Chinese gaokao is evaluated based on regions and the test takers’residency. Even so, economic imbalance within a region can still play a significant role. The United States faces similar challenges in its evaluation methodology. A holistic evaluation method also inevitably gives a hefty advantage to students from affluent families who can hire tutors, coaches, and mentors to help develop not only academics but also extracurricular activities. This is the reason colleges attempt to judge each applicant with consideration of their school and so-called individual environment.


  Poised at opposite ends of the spectrum, China and the United States would both like to move towards the middle to compensate for each other’s weaknesses in respective evaluation methods. In recent years, the debate about the soundness of Affirmative Action policy has intensified in the United States. The current Affirmative Action policy in the United States was introduced in 1961 to combat racial discrimination in the recruiting process. The concept was later expanded to address gender discrimination. While those considerations offer certain new angles to fairness in many cases, many argue that they introduce many non-quantitatively-definable factors which make the possibility of fair evaluation even more questionable.
  Everything leads back to fundamentals. The goal of elite higher education institutions is to cultivate future leaders who can generate a positive impact in various fields such as business, industry, science, art, research, and medicine. Neither the Chinese nor the American evaluation method is perfect. The key is how to best identify diverse talent, encourage students to pursue a well-rounded education, develop interests and passions, and engineer fairer evaluation criteria. The college admission process in both the East and the West will continue to face challenges.
其他文献
根据《卫生部关于印发2002年国家卫生监督抽检工作计划的通知》(卫法监发[2002]3号)要求,2002年第三季度,卫生部在全国组织了对健美、美乳、育发、烫发类化妆品的监督抽检工作,抽检工作依据《国家卫生监督抽检规定》和卫生部《化妆品卫生规范》实施和评价。    一、抽检结果  2002年第三季度共抽检健美、美乳、育发、烫发类化妆品58种,49种合格,合格率为84.5%。各类产品抽检情况如下:  
期刊
After more than a year of marvelous journey, a herd of wild Asian elephants finally returned to their traditional habitat in southwestern China’s Yunnan Province on September 10, 2021. During the unus
期刊
Back in 2016, Gu Bojian, who was pursuing his master’s degree at the Xishuangbanna Tropical Botanical Garden of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, conducted a survey of the monsoon forest in the valley
期刊
Since the end of the 1970s, especially since the turn of the century, China has been debating the reform of the national college entrance examination, popularly called the gaokao. Chu Zhaohui, a resea
期刊
This book is a memoir. The author recorded the youth and maturation of a generation with delicate and romantic words and images.  The author shares stories of his youth and his path to photography inc
期刊
Baby monkeys with gray and white fur jumped from branch to branch and occasionally cried out like human babies. An adult gray black monkey squatted under a tree, leisurely munching on the weeds beside
期刊
Every May, monsoons from the Pacific and Indian oceans bring abundant rainfall to southwestern China’s Yunnan Province, which makes it a paradise for wild mushrooms. How many types of mushrooms grow i
期刊
On September 10, 2021, the 14 “wandering” elephants returned to their previous habitat in Ning’er County, Pu’er City, in southwestern China’s Yunnan Province, marking an end to their 17-month trip nor
期刊
On October 21, 1977, I read an article titled “College Enrollment Embraces Major Reforms” in People’s Daily, which announced that candidates could start registering to participate in the gaokao. By th
期刊
With her one-month- old daughter in one arm and her threeyear-old in the other, Zhang Jiangyan boarded a ferry, bound for her mother’s home to avoid a flood.  Zhang lives in Longkou Village, Lianhu To
期刊